Opinion Crichton to miss dally ms

[_G-Dog_]

Willie Taulau will come in to take on his son Tommy..

 

[Disposable Hero]

With how soft the game has gone wouldnt be suprised if he gets suspended for 2 games or more which rules him out of dally m which is stupid

Your post is stupid

 

[Raikkonen]

If found he pleads or is found guilty, is he out of the dally m centre of the year contest, or just overall medal?

 

[Brendan7]

With how soft the game has gone wouldnt be suprised if he gets suspended for 2 games or more which rules him out of dally m which is stupid

He is still eligible both the rules have changed you lose 6 votes per week suspended (only eligible once a season fines are ok)

 

[Brendan7]

If found he pleads or is found guilty, is he out of the dally m centre of the year contest, or just overall medal?

Neither I swear I wish people would learn the new rules. Suspensions don’t rule you out of the positional awards, and you can get suspended once and still win the Dally M, you lose 6 votes per week suspension so Crighton would lose 6 for this week. That is it

 

[J_Cooper]

We’d have to be the only team in history to be worse off having a player not put in the sinbin. Because if he was he wouldn’t have copped a week. Anyways we’ll be sweet and Crichton will only be more hungry now.

 

[Dogs4eva13]

NRL punishing the injury not the act.

 

[pillow]

What a fucking joke

 

[Big_Kahunas]

This game has gone to the madhouse. A high shot use to be a swinging arm - like the hit Tracey and Taafe got in the Roosters game. These accidental shoulders are ridiculous.

COMMON SENSE would say Critta see's RTS coming and knows we have 2 defenders that are just about to tackle him. Does he
a) Shoulder charge him in the head on purpose.
b) Try and keep the defensive line close to the shoulder of his inside defender.

He didn't attack his head on purpose and it was an accident.

 

[Hopefully]

If RTS knocked out Critta using same tackle we will be blowing up.

 

[rainman]

He ran into his shoulder

 

[Hopefully]

This game has gone to the madhouse. A high shot use to be a swinging arm - like the hit Tracey and Taafe got in the Roosters game. These accidental shoulders are ridiculous.

COMMON SENSE would say Critta see's RTS coming and knows we have 2 defenders that are just about to tackle him. Does he
a) Shoulder charge him in the head on purpose.
b) Try and keep the defensive line close to the shoulder of his inside defender.

He didn't attack his head on purpose and it was an accident.

I agree it was minor but that's not how nrl been ruling on that all year any shoulder contact to the head is sin bin.

 

[Raikkonen]

Neither I swear I wish people would learn the new rules. Suspensions don’t rule you out of the positional awards, and you can get suspended once and still win the Dally M, you lose 6 votes per week suspension so Crighton would lose 6 for this week. That is it

Can you elaborate on the loss of 6 votes? Is he docked existing votes? Would he only loose votes if he got them this week?

 

[Brendan7]

Can you elaborate on the loss of 6 votes? Is he docked existing votes? Would he only loose votes if he got them this week?

Existing votes so look I don’t have the table but for arguments sake he was on 50 votes after this round (he’s not but it’s just easier for me to explain it), he would drop to 44 votes. You are eligible for ONE suspension per season.

 

[Kung fu man]

With how soft the game has gone wouldnt be suprised if he gets suspended for 2 games or more which rules him out of dally m which is stupid

Doubt it prob a fine

 

[pillow]

Doubt it prob a fine

The nrlol charged him, one week early plea, two weeks if he fights and loses. What an absolute joke.

 

[Kung fu man]

Grade 2 ffs this game might as well be touch football

 

[Raikkonen]

Existing votes so look I don’t have the table but for arguments sake he was on 50 votes after this round (he’s not but it’s just easier for me to explain it), he would drop to 44 votes. You are eligible for ONE suspension per season.

Thanks for the info. I don't really give a shit about Dally M's, but 6 votes is a significant cost.

 

[Brendan7]

Thanks for the info. I don't really give a shit about Dally M's, but 6 votes is a significant cost.

join the club the fact is Lockyer never won one and they like to give Hynes votes for having good hair says it all

Crighton was never winning it anyway Hughes will win by 10 plus votes it won’t be close. Crighton will get centre of the year and potentially captain of the year

 

[GoTheDoggies]

Who the fuck cares?

Didn't the bottle job Hynes win it? FFS Luai is miles better than him. The personal accolades mean jack shit.

Cleary hasn't won it yet has gone on a three-peat proves the award is a farce and joke.