Phalangist
Kennel Addict
- Joined
- May 6, 2013
- Messages
- 5,095
- Reaction score
- 3,895
why not Rod Silva?I feel like the presence of Luke Pattern can help DWZ game.
why not Rod Silva?I feel like the presence of Luke Pattern can help DWZ game.
Lol what a load of shit. By that logic no one over the age of 35 could transition into specialist position coach.Luke Patten was a favourite of mine but the fullback position has changed in so many ways since he played and I doubt he would be good at teaching much except the basics.
Hes a coppa and its been 30 yearswhy not Rod Silva?
20 yearsHes a coppa and its been 30 years
Once again you show your basic footy knowledge. If you think fullbacks and hookers haven’t evolved in the last decade you are kidding yourself.Lol what a load of shit. By that logic no one over the age of 35 could transition into specialist position coach.
Patten would be one bloke who could turn his hand to working with fullbacks effectively if he wanted to. Stellar career in the position followed by studying the game in the decade post-retirement.
Lol and where did I dispute that? I’m disputing your opinion that you can’t effectively coach either of those positions unless you’ve played there in the past 5-10 years.Once again you show your basic footy knowledge. If you think fullbacks and hookers haven’t evolved in the last decade you are kidding yourself.
Yes, but Pattern would go well with Hodgkinson, Lafia and Pea.I feel like the presence of Luke Pattern can help DWZ game.
Patten was a basic and reliable fullback but a limited one especially in today’s game so he’s limited in what he can teach. I’m talking specifically about Patten not everyone.Lol and where did I dispute that? I’m disputing your opinion that you can’t effectively coach either of those positions unless you’ve played there in the past 5-10 years.
I dont think you could question his commitment or heart mate ,He was in a good era yes and bled blue n white for the club .Meaney has nothing on the General ,not even close .He was one of the unluckiest players to ever not don an Australian Jersey due to the era and other fullback competition .Consistently a threat ,try scorer and reliable .Th problem with Pattens was he had no heart at all, and it was paved over by being part of a golden age of Bulldog teams.
don’t get me wrong, he was a skilful good player. But it’s funny how he just ‘tripped’ at the line so much to avoid getting hurt.
If he was in the modern team he would be considered a fraud (he isn’t).
he’s probably similar to Meaney in a lot of ways
So the bloke who the Panthers hired to work closely with their halves who’s played no higher than reserve grade 15 years ago must be completely useless to coach in the NRL today under your exact logic;Patten was a basic and reliable fullback but a limited one especially in today’s game so he’s limited in what he can teach. I’m talking specifically about Patten not everyone.
No idea it’s irrelevant to what I’m talking about as I made it pretty clear is was referring to only Patten but you seem to have trouble comprehending that.So the bloke who the Panthers hired to work closely with their halves who’s played no higher than reserve grade 15 years ago must be completely useless to coach in the NRL today under your exact logic;
- wasn’t an elite player
- didn’t play within the past 5-10 years
This. 2 times dally m winner. Would be a good fullback in today’s game with his kicking skills and ball playing ability.We've got Mick Potter