Marley was right

[bringitontm]

Almost everyone on here last year would get the shits when Marley would pretty much say that Josh Reynolds should not be anywhere near a football and hammered him week in week out. Marley was right. The guy is the worst 5/8 I have ever seen play the game.

He should take his boots and move on. He can not kick, can not pass, can not run threw gaps.
Remember in 2014 when Trex played 5/8 and looked way better then him. That said it all.

I don't care if we run on the field with 12 players we are better off with out him. Anyone who can not see that is in another world.

 

[Boxer]

That's your opinion, his not the best but his the best we got so live with it.

 

[Kempsey Dog]

Ive lost all patience with him. Use to be my favourite..... not now... Showing as much class as Dylan Walker in the 6.... Sad

 

[habs]

Reynolds is terrible... He is way too inconsistent. Would suit the Titans or some other substandard club.

 

[Interestingg]

Unfortunately the game has moved past Reynolds. He would've killed it in the 80's though

 

[bringitontm]

That's your opinion, his not the best but his the best we got so live with it.

How do you know he is the best we have when no one else had been given a chance.

 

[Boxer]

How do you know he is the best we have when no one else had been given a chance.

Well ask the master mind des I think that's his job.

 

[Interestingg]

How do you know he is the best we have when no one else had been given a chance.

Chisholm is creative but just as erratic and Frawley has shown next to nothing in 2 years. Why do you think rumours about Luke Brooks keep popping up

 

[Spoonman84]

A big worry is Moses playing with Reynolds and how much it effects his long term development. He provides nothing I don't care if anyone says he's passionate we are all passionate about the club it doesn't mean we should be a half at the club.

 

[Özil]

Reynolds is not a 5/8... he's a hooker.

And Mbye is a 6... we really need a halfback that can work with Mbye.

 

[bringitontm]

Reynolds is not a 5/8... he's a hooker.

And Mbye is a 6... we really need a halfback that can work with Mbye.

If des insists on keeping him in the team. Give him a shot at hooker. Could be a great hooker or the worst 5/8 of all time.

 

[Mr Invisible]

DCE isn't doing so great recently either.

Are we just going to forget Reynolds first game this season?

 

[Vlasnik]

Unfortunately the game has moved past Reynolds. He would've killed it in the 80's though

With the likes of Steve Mortimer, Terry Lamb, Craig Polla-Mounter, Brent Sherwin even Braith Anasta I doubt it.

 

[Vlasnik]

DCE isn't doing so great recently either.

Are we just going to forget Reynolds first game this season?

The whole Manly team aint doing so great but at least they have an excuse for sucking call cohesion the bulk of our team has been playing together for a few years now and Reynolds has been apart of that team. So we're not looking at 1 game there are many games you can look at over the last 4 years.

 

[finchie]

It's not all his fault
I'd sack a few others before I got to him tbh
Maybe our mastermind coach instructing the players to stand flat as a surfboard not helping him out one iota

 

[Weak Gutted Dog]

Ive lost all patience with him. Use to be my favourite..... not now... Showing as much class as Dylan Walker in the 6.... Sad

Can't agree more.
I used to admire his passion but there is no creativity

 

[CrittaMagic69]

Ofcourse he is a crap half lol. But every half is going to struggle playing within Des' current structure. JT wouldn't be able to do shit playing within these atm. It is ridiculous

 

[Vlasnik]

It's not all his fault
I'd sack a few others before I got to him tbh
Maybe our mastermind coach instructing the players to stand flat as a surfboard not helping him out one iota

The direction of the team lays solely on his and Mbyes shoulders and since Reynolds is the senior member of that partnership the blame is always going to fall upon him!!!

 

[finchie]

So the forwards standing right beside him, not running from deep and hitting holes is his fault too vlas?

 

[CrittaMagic69]

It's not all his fault
I'd sack a few others before I got to him tbh
Maybe our mastermind coach instructing the players to stand flat as a surfboard not helping him out one iota

Reynolds would be my first sacked tbh