Who would win, all players in their prime

[Bad Billy]

Team 1. Mortimer and lamb to demonstrate their significance, swap them to the other side, and they'd win

 

[habs]

Team 2 by 25+

 

[Abdul..]

Chris Anderson in plade of Hazem. Andrew Farrar in the centers. Hiw could you leave Farrar out?

 

[Doginator]

Jonathon THURSTON?

 

[Ghost of Dime]

Where is Hickey you degenerate fcking plebs

 

[Natboy]

Where is Hickey you degenerate fcking plebs

Revesby maccas

 

[DezDog]

1:barba
2allas
3:Hagan
4:Morris
5:inu
6:Lamb
7:Mortimer
8:Browman
9:Hetherington
10:Graham
11:Swb
12:Kelly
13:Clyde

14:Thurston 15:robbo 16:shrek 17:dymock

 

[Freakzilla]

For our current Bulldogs team I'd take Terry Lamb over SBW at their peak. Our team needs another half, someone that supports the forwards and someone to teach the rest of the team toughness and heart. No way on earth would T-Rex get away with what he does if Terry Lamb was in the team.

 

[Doggies 2035]

Man imagine people like terry lamb and Steve mort playing and training like the top grade players of today they be beast

 

[Doggies 2035]

Man imagine people like terry lamb and Steve mort playing and training like the top grade players they be beast

 

[Junkyard]

Some of our best forwards EVER - not mentioned - Dean Pay, Dymock (both defectors in the day) - are behind these guys, Matua too
David Gillespie
Steve Folkes
Peter Tunks
Kevin Ryan
Peter Kelly
Then there's the matter of Fullback - what about Les Johns
El Masri will ALWAYS be a first choice

Maybe we need a thread of our best EVER players

 

[Freakzilla]

Pay and Dymock are better than Folkes, Tunks and Kelly.

 

[sedgy13]

Best bulldogs ive seen

1: Greg Brentnall
2: Chris Anderson
3: Andrew Farrer
4: Darren Smith
5: Hasem Elmasri
6: Terry Lamb
7: Steve Mortimer
8: Peter Kelly
9: Jason Hethrington
10: Darren Britt
11: David Gillespie
12: Steve Price
13: Jim Dymock

14: Paul Dunn
15: Simon Gillies
16: Chris Mortimer
17: Dean Pay

And reckon i could name a second team and still not have SBW

 

[DogsFan4Life]

Thats bs ill give u team
1.B.barba (2012 form)
2.hazem.
3.farrer
4.mc cracken
5.matt utai
6.t.lamb
7.sherwin/mortimer
8.kasiano
9.heterington
10.tunks
11.j.smith
12 $bw
13. Dymock

thats a teammmm

 

[CroydonDog]

I appreciate we are simply giving our opinions and it encourages some fun debate, but mate, are you seriously putting Sherwin on par with Turvey? He's the reason I started following the dogs 30 years ago.

Sent from my C5303 using Tapatalk

 

[Snowmann]

A combined team would be a dream.

01. Ben Barba
02. Hazem El Masri (k)
03. Darren Smith
04. Willie Tonga
05. Nigel Vagana
06. Terry Lamb (vc)
07. Steve Mortimer (c)
08. Darren Britt
09. Jason Hethrington
10. Dean Pay
11. Willie Mason
12. Sonny Bill-Williams
13. Jim Dymock

14. Mark O'Meley
15. Andrew Ryan
16. Travis Norton
17. Ewan McGrady

Take out Norton and put in Price.

 

[sedgy13]

Thats bs ill give u team
1.B.barba (2012 form)
2.hazem.
3.farrer
4.mc cracken
5.matt utai
6.t.lamb
7.sherwin/mortimer
8.kasiano
9.heterington
10.tunks
11.j.smith
12 $bw
13. Dymock

thats a teammmm

Kelly would smash Kasiano and id love to see Gillespie Pay and C Mortimer get there hands on SBW

 

[sedgy13]

I appreciate we are simply giving our opinions and it encourages some fun debate, but mate, are you seriously putting Sherwin on par with Turvey? He's the reason I started following the dogs 30 years ago.

Sent from my C5303 using Tapatalk

Can only agree there. Turvey just behind Lamb as best Bulldog ive ever watched

 

[Kayser]

Best bulldogs ive seen

1: Greg Brentnall
2: Chris Anderson
3: Andrew Farrer
4: Darren Smith
5: Hasem Elmasri
6: Terry Lamb
7: Steve Mortimer
8: Peter Kelly
9: Jason Hethrington
10: Darren Britt
11: David Gillespie
12: Steve Price
13: Jim Dymock

14: Paul Dunn
15: Simon Gillies
16: Chris Mortimer
17: Dean Pay

And reckon i could name a second team and still not have SBW

1:Les Johns
2: El Magic
3: Josh
4: D. Smith
5: Dallas (too quick)

6: Baa
7: Turvey

8: Tunks
9: Hethrington
10: Britt
11: $BW
12: Jason Smith
13: Jimmy D

14: Pay
15: Price
16: Kelly
17: Cement

 

[speedy2460]

People who are picking these teams obviously have never seen Les Johns...