but finals footy would still exceed expectations
I don't think so. We have a very decent footy team now and should expect to compete.
7-10 is par I would think. We should expect to be there or there abouts.
comparing our spine to others
Actually, it's comparing our spine (this year) to ourselves (last year).
We have:
* Mahoney (a HUGE upgrade on JMK)
* Burton (a year older, more experienced, settled, and I have no better)
* Flanagan (sans the Barrett nerf and now with the Ciraldo buff. He might not be the '24 & beyond option, or even end up playing out '23 as first choice half, but I fully expect the '23:Flanagan+Ciraldo offering to be wildly better than the '22:Flanagan-Barrett debacle).
*Averillo (ditto for the Flanagan scenario. He will be much improved under Ciraldo. Whether that locks him in as fullback, or he ends up at centre or the bench...we'll see).
Max King (enough said), a fired-up TPJ, a rejuvenated Luke Thompson, and a smokey from Sutton, Pele, or Hughes, all under the expectation and guidance of Ciraldo should see a much improved '23 approach over '22. Add Kikau on the left edge and we should be expecting much better go-forward.