NRL Round 11 | Non Bulldogs Team Lists & Discussions

[coach]

Yep and for getting a black eye

That was a joke, although yapping blokes like walker need a touch up
Storm lost sin bins galore, walker with a black eye
I'm guna say what a great game lol

 

[Freakzilla]

Well guess what ? According to OP it was the NRL timekeeper who gave permission even though the Melbourne official protested about it.
You can be binned if it is deemed to be enough to have caused a greater problem and that player needs to cool off....#Obviously it can be up to discretion on the official onfield.

Sin Bin The #six main reasons for a player to be temporarily suspended for ten minutes are: 1. Repeated infringements 2. Professional Foul 3. Cooling off period for a player 4. Dissent 5. Striking 6. Foul Play* * Foul Play – A player will be sin binned for foul play in circumstances where, in the opinion of the Referee, the foul play does not warrant sending off, but is serious enough to place the player on report, and the player injured from the foul play is unlikely to take any further part in the game.

Walker didn't need a cooling off period. He wasn't doing anything wrong.

 

[adamsapple]

Walker is out for 6 weeks
Would his injury make matters worse for Scott

I hope he gets atleast 5 weeks on the sideline only because i hate Melbourne

 

[Kaz]

Walker is out for 6 weeks
Would his injury make matters worse for Scott

It shouldn't.

But it did when Alex McKinnon was hurt, Jordan McLean got extra weeks because of the injury.

 

[CaptainJackson]

Dragons being gifted the game

 

[GoTheDoggies]

Dufty embarrasses the Faders defence

 

[chisdog]

How can people in the nrl sit back and accept this corruption.

It's not a rort if you are in on it.

 

[chisdog]

Sutton would have said that wasn't a knock-on.

 

[chisdog]

Has anyone EVER seen ANY player EVER penalised or even sin binned for leading with the head?????

There's a new rule with foul play

 

[pillow]

There's a new rule with foul play

Wasn’t Napa cleared by the MRC though?

 

[chisdog]

Wasn’t Napa cleared by the MRC though?

Yep, but the video referee said is was foul play & they can put it in the bin. They don't know what the MRC are going to do during the game.

 

[pillow]

Yep, but the video referee said is was foul play & they can put it in the bin. They don't know what the MRC are going to do during the game.

Cleared by mrc after the game, indicating that it was an incorrect call by the ref on field

 

[chisdog]

Cleared by mrc after the game, indicating that it was an incorrect call by the ref on field

That doesn't mean it was an incorrect call by the video ref though

 

[chisdog]

another knock-on not called

 

[dogluva]

Walker didn't need a cooling off period. He wasn't doing anything wrong.

What? So his usual grand effort of sledging accompanying the big cat grin on his face all game was fine and not ramping up the tension on field.

He did not like it one bit when it happened to him in that Penrith game after he had been at a Penrith player for the full 80.

There is no place in the game for sledging particularly sledging that garnered the response from the other player involved in the incident. Walker and Scott were separated by Hoffman and then Walker pushed his way back and shoved Scott, then grabbed him around the neck and shouted a string of insults at him....that to me looked a lot like inciting the response that came.......AND led to his stint in the bin to cool off and think about what he said and did and what followed...

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-05-20/curtis-scott-sent-off-for-punching-dylan-walker-in-nrl/9780546

 

[Freakzilla]

What? So his usual grand effort of sledging accompanying the big cat grin on his face all game was fine and not ramping up the tension on field.

He did not like it one bit when it happened to him in that Penrith game after he had been at a Penrith player for the full 80.

There is no place in the game for sledging particularly sledging that garnered the response from the other player involved in the incident. Walker and Scott were separated by Hoffman and then Walker pushed his way back and shoved Scott, then grabbed him around the neck and shouted a string of insults at him....that to me looked a lot like inciting the response that came.......AND led to his stint in the bin to cool off and think about what he said and did and what followed...

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-05-20/curtis-scott-sent-off-for-punching-dylan-walker-in-nrl/9780546

You're allowed to sledge. I have no issue with it. It's been in the game for 100 years.

 

[Bob dog]

Why take a first grade game to an undeserved dump in the hills?

 

[Dawgfather]

Yep, but the video referee said is was foul play & they can put it in the bin. They don't know what the MRC are going to do during the game.

If the video ref think it's a chargeable offence, but the MRC say it's not, isn't there an argument to say the video ref is getting way too involved and should be keeping his judgements to try scoring opportunities?

 

[Dawgfather]

There is no place in the game for sledging particularly sledging that garnered the response from the other player involved in the incident.

I hope this part was sarcastic.

Do you really want referees and the NRL in general to start policing what is said on the field? That would be absolutely ridiculous.

If grown men want to talk smack to each other on the field, then let them!

 

[OITENTA-E-NOVE]

I hope this part was sarcastic.

Do you really want referees and the NRL in general to start policing what is said on the field? That would be absolutely ridiculous.

If grown men want to talk smack to each other on the field, then let them!

then let them swing if they feel. the no punch rule has people out there talking reckless