Opinion Club Legends, El Masri vs Jackson.

[CrittaMagic69]

Who in your opinion is more deserving of club legend status at our club? Are neither worthy?

Please vote honestly, SERIOUS DISCUSSION ONLY.

Edit: Now that we've got this out of the way, what players would you consider club legends?

 

[Bazildog]

I seriously think Marley is cooked.

 

[CrittaMagic69]

I seriously think Marley is cooked.

 

[CrittaMagic69]

@Dognacious is it possible to pin this? Very important topic and the more eyes on here the better.

 

[Bulldogsteve]

Who in your opinion is more deserving of club legend status at our club? Are neither worthy?

Please vote honestly, SERIOUS DISCUSSION ONLY.

You need to quote the stats
Jackson 2 Australian and 9 SOO games
Brad fittler medal for player of the series
Bulldogs captain

hazem
1 game each for Australia and SOO

no comparison

 

[CrittaMagic69]

You need to quote the stats
Jackson 2 Australian and 9 SOO games
Brad fittler medal for player of the series
Bulldogs captain

hazem
1 game each for Australia and SOO

no comparison

Australian born Jackson played more Australian rep related games than Lebanese born El Masri? No way.

 

[Apex Cedar]

Would not be a discussion if Hazem changed his name to Harry Edwards

 

[Haddaway]

Do you have to do something of Legend, to be called a Legend?

 

[KLil]

Simple way to end the discussion... One is a Legend and the other is a LEBgend!

 

[TABOO]

Who in your opinion is more deserving of club legend status at our club? Are neither worthy?

Please vote honestly, SERIOUS DISCUSSION ONLY.

Matt Dufty

 

[billy beane]

Neither are legends in my view. That is reserved for Johns, Mortimer, Lamb, Folkes and perhaps Peponis (Australian captain)

Who would i rather have at present in their primes ?

El masri because of his great goalkicking.

 

[Bazildog]

Dumbest thread ever. Not even Nasheed or Blueboost could make this shit up..

 

[Doge]

Is this real?

 

[billy beane]

Dumbest thread ever. Not even Nasheed or Blueboost could make this shit up..

Why ?

 

[kmr07]

You need to quote the stats
Jackson 2 Australian and 9 SOO games
Brad fittler medal for player of the series
Bulldogs captain

hazem
1 game each for Australia and SOO

no comparison

You can’t compare players based on rep games. It really depends what era they played in and who was in front in their position. E.g. Brent Sherwin never played origin and he was miles better than other players who have played origin e.g. Jamie Soward, Brett Finch

 

[billy beane]

You can’t compare players based on rep games. It really depends what era they played in and who was in front in their position. E.g. Brent Sherwin never played origin and he was miles better than other players who have played origin e.g. Jamie Soward, Brett Finch

100%

 

[Marki]

I see it as who is/was most valuable in the team, and i tend feel its Hazem.

We've never been a team that scores significantly more tries than the opposition so over the years we have relied on ensuring 4 turns to 6 and opposition not wanting to give away penalties willy nilly.

Its Hazem more me.

 

[Disposable Hero]

Both served the club in thier own way.
And Both are club legends in thier own right.
You cannot compare the 2.

 

[Moedogg]

Anyone who spends over a decade at a club is a legend in my books.

El Masri ate off Shifty's boot

Jackson did the hardwork in the middle

Both are still legends.

 

[Bazildog]

Why ?

Because of a thing called context. Marley was trying to rubbish Jackson in another thread and used El Masri as his example of a legend to dis him.

Like any Bulldog supporter I love Hazem, but I am not stupid enough to think that as a footballer he is better than Jackson.