Which you are more than entitled to. I think he definitly had moments of quality (which i mentioned several times in my updates and review of the game that i actually attended)
To point me out as someone who only criticised Roberts is unfair and ridiculous
I actually did object here..
http://www.thekennel.net.au/forum/showthread.php?t=84549&p=2360983&highlight=#post2360983
I think saying he was excellent is disregarding the difference in quality between the grades and the fact this team and Roberts should dominate beyond what he is doing
He played ok in a NSW cup team. If you actually read what i said, i said he did some good things and some bad things. I said he wasnt a stand out and i absolutely stand by that.
If you read my updates on the game you will see i also praised him at times.
He wasnt great by any means. This team...
Wasnt our night from the get go! Nothing we tried came close to coming off. But for 50 minutes we were outclassed and outenthused.
Melbourne are clinical, methodical, well coached and near impossible to beat at home. They were on and we were off. Not our best! But we didn't roll over and take...
Bias at its best putting hunt in the same class as slater.
They are brilliant and exciting to watch! I enjoy a clinical melbourne display.. Preferably against another team haha
We wont have 4 specialist forwards, but we will be replacing a forward with a forward.
You raise some valid points but roberts isnt what we are missing