What would you prefer

[boggie23]

Hey this is just a simple question.


if you were the coach of a football team which mentality would you go for.


all out attack or all out defence.

no fence sitting


would you like to win 44-40

or do you like 10-6 better.



which team would you build and why????

 

[Leesee]

all out defence. common sense says that. you can attack, but defence will win you a game. a 10-6 game proves that defence will win you a game. define the second part of this question and i will get back to you

 

[Fender]

Defence. You can't lose a game if your opponents can't score points.

 

[*Karlz*]

I like the fence thank you very much Defence. As its been said, you cant win without defence. However, in saying that, if you have no attack, you wont necessarily win either. Draw isnt good enough for me

 

[SBW]

Defence Wins games, so i would say defence

 

[TdoggBulldog]

Defence. You can't lose a game if your opponents can't score points.

exactly!!

 

[boggie23]

i sort of agree


but if you have a team of tacklers

can you score???

 

[*Karlz*]

i sort of agree


but if you have a team of tacklers

can you score???

My point exactly, except you said it in a far less confusing way, lol.

 

[PantherPower83]

Attack - it has been proven that you don't need the best defence to win a premiership.

 

[atomic_crimson]

i would go with defence... points can be scored off defence as seen with the bulldogs...

you can't stop points with attack

 

[cljunior]

i would go with defence... points can be scored off defence as seen with the bulldogs...

you can't stop points with attack

I don't think that's completely right though. Some teams can have good defense, but a team like the Dragons like week can still obilterate you.

 

[Chicharito]

its hard 2 say if u wanna go out n play defence or go out n attack...u gotta ave a balance of both...if u can play gud defence then ur attack can roll off that....u jus need a gud combination both attack n defence

 

[matt]

attack for mine,

if u have poor attack and good defence, then ull end up defending ur line too much (from failed attacking chances), getting tired and in the end leaking points anyway. thats my chain of thought anyway

 

[boggie23]

ok then what will be more entertaining


a match of attack where 80 points are scored in the game

or a defensive game where under 20 points are scored.



i know what i like


i love defensive games where it is like war and every meter is hard earnt


like SOO type games.

 

[boggie23]

and also what sort of mentality do you think the dogs are



i can only think of one player off the top of my head that can not defend

utai



so what does that then say about the team?????