on talent alone, SBW belongs there but in his 5 seasons in FG with the Dogs, 2 were interrupted by injury, and one by his walk out... fair enough, he does return to the NRL with the Roosters and wins another premiership but still, no. 8 is too high
Tallis was a bit overrated and i am not sure he deserves to be in the top 10... for example, i think Ben Kennedy was every bit as good as a second rower, and Webcke the premier prop in the game during the same time
Thurston probably deserves to be above Lockyer, although both were great
Cameron Smith unlucky not to be no. 1
