Should players from other clubs have voting rights with their ex clubs ?

[rwalker999]

I dont think they should.

If they leave a club I think they should resign from the football club and relinquish their voting rights.

Currently Wee Willie is still trying to stir the pot at the Dogs. he created enough damage and bad blood while he was with us and he is still trying to put in the knife.

Perhaps the question could be IQ related, which would ensure that a chook that always carried on like a turkey could take his personal baggage with him wherever he went.

Regards,
Russell

 

[buster]

agree

 

[S.B.W_Jnr]

I dont think they should.

If they leave a club I think they should resign from the football club and relinquish their voting rights.

Currently Wee Willie is still trying to stir the pot at the Dogs. he created enough damage and bad blood while he was with us and he is still trying to put in the knife.

Perhaps the question could be IQ related, which would ensure that a chook that always carried on like a turkey could take his personal baggage with him wherever he went.

Regards,
Russell

i agree they shouldnt vote but with mason being against the current board im with him on that forsure...

 

[RobDog55er]

Mason is not a voting member.

List of Voting Football Club Members
Mr Buddy Abouharb
Mr Allan Aggett
Mr John William Agland
Mr David Aldridge
Ms Christine Aldridge
Mr Albert Alonso
Mr Maxwell Amidy
Mr Trevor Anderson
Mr Charles John Anderson
Mr Chris Anderson
Mr Fred Anderson
Mrs Joan Andrews
Mr Richard Appleyard
Ms Kim Archer
Mr Paul Archer
Mr Gregory Mark Aspinall
Mr Yianni Athanasopoulos
Mr Dale Conrad Atkins
Mr Leslie Raymond Atkins
Mr John Harold Austin
Mr Phillip Auswild
Mr Mark Auswild
Mr Trevor Auswild
Mr Anthony Blake Ayshford
Mr Harold Alan Bains
Mr John Ballesty
Mr George Peter Barakat
Mr Terry Barry-James
Mr Les Bateman
Mr Bob Baxter
Mr Michael Thomas Beck
Mr Gavin Beecroft
Mr Spiro Bellas
Mr Brian J Beynon
Mr John Bhuruth
Mrs Joan Blake
Mr Robert Blake
Mr Gordon Bobbin
Mr Steven Brian Bogie
Mr Stuart Booth
Mr Norman Boustany
Mr David Bowman
Mr Kevin Alfred Brennan
Mr Craig Frederick Brennan
Mr Scott C Brennan
Mr Bernard Charles
Brennan
Mr Gordon Brian
Mr Larry Britton
Mr Shane Brodie
Mr Ray Broneske
Mr John Joseph Brown
Mr Lionel Hubert Brown
Mr Col Brown
Mr Anthony Burke
Ms June Burnes
Mr Kenneth Byass
Mr Mark Byrnes
Mr James Arthur Calver
Mr Ian Camlett
Mr Gary Campbell
Mr Garry John Carden
Mr John Carmody
Mr Victor Carnuccio
Mr John Daniel Carolan
Mr Edward Francis Carolan,
O.A.M
Mr Geoffrey Carpenter
Mr Reginald Thomas
Cassidy
Mr Peter Cassilles
Mr Joe Cautela
Mr Laurie Cavill
Mr Adam Cawley
Mr Joseph Chahine
Mr Michael Chahoud
Mr Phillip Charlton
Mr Tony Charlton
Mr Ken Charlton
Mr Elias Chebl
Mr John Chidiac
Mr Napoleon Christopoulos
Mr Fred Ciraldo
Ms Gail Clark
Mr Harold Clark
Mr Peter Clarke
Mr Ross Michael Cleary
Mr Ken Clendinning
Mr Malcolm Clift
Mr Kenneth Albert Clifton
Mr Brian Clunas
Mr Barry Clunas
Mr Bradley Clyde
Mr John Coates
Mrs Joan Cole
Mr Allan John Collings
Mrs Judith Collins
Mr John Collins
Mr Anthony Colliver
Mr Geoffrey Connell
Mr Gregory Cook
Ms Natalie Cook
Mr Lesley Cook
Ms Patricia Cook
Mr Ian Malcolm Cook
Mr Dave Cooper
Mrs Laurel Coorey
Mr George Coorey
Mr Vincent John Coorey
Mr Arthur Coorey
Mr Dale Corliss
Mr Neville Lawrence Corrie
Mr William John Cowley
Mr Clint Crofts
Mr Frank Crumpton
Mr Greg Cullen
Mr John Patrick Cullen
Mr Stan Cutler
Mr Gabi Dagher
Mr Antoin Dagher
Mr Danny Daher
Mr George Danas
Mr Geoffrey David Davis
Mr Ronald William Davis
Mr Westby James Davoren
Mr Walter Frederick Dawes
Mr Kevin Dawes
Mr Leslie Francis Dee
Mr Charlie Deeb
Mr Adam DeGiorgio
Mr David DeGiorgio
Mr Bill Diakanastasis
Mr David Dib
Mr Ray Dib
Mr Eris Andrew Dignam
Mr Ciro Di-Iorio
Mr Nicholas Dimas
Mr Jim Dimas
Mr Chris Dimou
Mr Nick Dionisopoulos
Mr Christopher Dodds
Mr Lawrence Bernard
Dodds
Mr Lindsay Domingue
Mr Thomas Henry Dooner
Mr Spiro Doukas
Mr Con Doumbos
Mr Raymond Thomas
Downie
Mr Clayton Drury
Mr Raymond Drury
Mr Robert Dubois
Mr Jack Dummett
Mr Loftus Charles Dun
Mr Peter Reginald Durose
Mr Bruce Leslie Dyball
Mr Raymond Francis Earl
Ms Susan Eastman
Mr Mark Edmonds
Mr Anthony Elias
Mr Les Elias
Mr John Wayne Ellis
Mr John Charles Ellis
Mr David M Evans
Mr Noel Thomas Evans
Mr Isuf Exhaj
Hon John Fahey
Mr Ash Fakhoury
Mr Roger Falconer
Mr Frank Farhart
Mr Ray Farrah
Mr Andrew Farrar
Mr Gordon Ferrier
Mr Michael Finch
Mr Joseph Finianos
Mr Rodney Finn
Ms Belinda Finn
Ms Isabella Flasza
Mr Frank William Fleming
Mr Steven Folkes
Mr David Francis
Mr Marlon Fraser
Mr Bradley Freney
Mr John Leslie Fullarton
Mr Napoleon Paul Andrew
Gahdmar
Mr Noel James Gale
Mr Wayne Galea
Miss Elizabeth Garland
Ms Violet Gartner
Mr Clive Gartner
Mr Abbie Giambuzzi
Miss Lisetta Giambuzzi
Mr Simon Gillies
Mr Barry James Gilmore
Mr Edward Goulding
Ms Sandy Green
Mr Jason Green
Ms Kayee Griffin
Mr John Thomas Griffin
Mr Kelvin Haak
Mr Allan John Haddad
Mr Vincent Paul Haddad
Mr David Anthony Haddad
Mr Christopher Haddad
Mr Robert Hagan
Mr Glenn William Hall
Mr James Anthony Hall
Mr Daryl Halligan
Mr Arthur Hanna
Mrs Sybil Hanna
Mr Louis Hanna
Mr Andrew Hanna
Mr John Francis Hanna
Mr Colin Hanna
Mr Peter John Hanna
Mr Lester Hanson
Mrs Catherine Harborne
Mr Roger Arthur Harborne
Mr Kenneth Harding
Mr Greg Hartley
Mr John Hatzistergos
Dr Hugh Hazard
Mr Ronald Sydenham
Hearn
Mrs Beryl Hearn
Mr Sean Hegarty
Mr John Michael Hegarty
Mr Louis Hendricks
Ms Vera Hill
Mr Keith Hill
Mr Joe Hills
Mr John William Hingerty
Mr Terrence Peter Hogan
Mr Mark Hogan
Mr Matthew Hollands
Ms Margaret Hollands
Mr Brian Holmes
Mr Brian Horne
Mr Eric Charles Horne
Mr Kenneth Francis Hottes
Mrs Maureen Huckstadt
Mrs Shirley Hudson
Mr David Hudson
Mr Noel Keith Hughes
Mr Graeme Hughes
Mr Mark Hughes
Mr Garry Hughes
Mr Glen Hughes
Mr Steven Hughes
Mr Colin Hugo
Mr Robert Allan Hunt
Mr Patrick Hunter
Mr Mark Hutchinson
Mr Victor James
Hutchinson
Mr Anthony James Hyland
Mr Steve Imbruglia
Mr Ken Ingall
Mr Anter Isaac
Mr Owen Isaac
Mr David Islip
Mr Bruce James
Mr Donald James Jamieson
Mr Henry Joseph Janowski
Mrs Rotha Jennings
Mr Alfred John Jennings
Mr Jim Joannou
Mr Leslie Johns
Mr Gary Stephen Jones
Mr John Jones
Mr Tony Joukhador
Mr Nick Kalaitzakis
Mr Patrick Kane
Mr Chris Karabetsos
Mr Theo Karabetsos
Mr Pirjo Karonen
Mr John Katelanis
Mr John Kavanagh
Mr John Douglas Kearns
Mr Charles Edward
Keighran
Mr Steven Joseph Kelly
Mr Joseph Donald Kelly
Mr John Jospeh Kennedy
Mr Warren Herman King
Mr Sidney Russell Kirk
Mr Ross Kline
Mr George Christopher
Kondis
Mr Con Koromilas
Mr Hristos Kouroupakis
Mr Jim Koutsouklakis
Mr Terry Lamb
Mr Thomas Lamont
Mrs Stephanie Lander
Mr Peter Henry Lander
Mr Malcolm Larsen
Mr Maurice Walter Layton
Mr Chris Maxwell Lee
Mr Barry Lehman
Mr Anthony Lemura
Mr Patrick Leung
Mr Gregg Levett
Mr Mark Steven Lewis
Mr Howard Lewis
Mr Geoffrey Lewis
Ms Carolyn Lewis
Ms Ethel Lewis
Mr Brian George Lindsay
Mr Joseph Lipari
Mr Glenn Long
Mr William Lor
Mrs Marjorie Lotty
Mr David Francis Lotty
Mr Robert Ernest Lotty
Mr Keith James Lotty
Mr Toby Lysaught
Mr Allan Reginald Lythall
Mr Fraser Maclennan-Pike
Ms Chyrel Madigan
Mr Garry Peter Maher
Mr Harry Mansour
Mr Richard Edmund
Marlow
Mr Graham Scott Martin
Mr Charlie Marzin
Mr George Mathioydahis
Mr George Matis
Mr Grant Mayer
Mr Edward Vincent McCall
Mr Laurie McCormack
Mr Rory Devlin McCrudden
Mr Michael McCrudden
Mr Kevin McDermott
Mr Ken McDonald
Mr Kevin James McEvoy
Mr Sean McGlynn
Mr Martin Ronald McGrath
Mr Ronald John McGrath
Mr Patrick McGuire
Mr David John McIntyre
Mr Gary John McIntyre
Mr David Bruce McLean
Mr Leo McLeay
Mr Ronald John McLeod
Mr Brian McNally
Mr Robert McNamara
Mr Gordon Anthony
McPherson
Mr Colin McPherson
Mr Anthony Milham
Mr John Mockett
Mr Geoffrey Mockett
Mr James Montague
Mrs Marie Moore
Mr Kevin Moore
Mr Peter Morris
Mr Joseph Morrison
Mr Stephen Mortimer
Mr Steve Mortimer
Mr Chris Mortimer
Mr Peter Mortimer
Mr Kevin Moss
Mr Michael Mulvihill
Mr Brian Joseph Mulvihill
Mr Lindsay Murphy
Mr Cyril Henry Murray
Mr Andrew Nehme
Mrs Beverly Dawn Nelson
Mr Scott Nelson
Mr Barry Clyde Nelson
Mr Alby Newman
Mr Michael Bruce Newson
Mr Mitch Newton
Mr Peter Niblock
Mr Brian George Nicey
Mr George Michael Nicey
Mr Roger Nicey
Mr Kevin Richard Nicey
Mr Aki Nicolinas
Mr William Noonan
Mr Andrew David O’Brien
Mr Peter O’Brien
Mr Barry John O’Brien
Mr Joseph O’Brien
Ms James Thomas O’Brien
Mr Hilary Daniel O’Connell
Mr Michael O’Donnell
Mr Kenneth Ross O’Farrell
Mr Mike O’Hara
Ms Vicki O’Mullane
Mr Matthew O’Neill
Mr Arsenios Papoulias
Mr Bill Parasiris
Mr Mihali Patsias
Mr Michael Vincent Patulny
Mr Oliver David Pearson
Mr Phil Pellizzeri
Ms Janette Penman
Mrs Dale Peponis
Dr George Peponis
Mr Reginald Perrett
Mr James Anthony Peters
Mr Douglas Pettiford
Mr David Petts
Mr Barry Phillis
Mr Stephen Philpott
Mr Manjinder Phull
Mr Tim Pickup
Mr Paul Pike
Mr Ruben Pintos
Mr Craig Polla-Mounter
Mr John Pont
Mr Kerril Powell
Mr James Powers
Mr Steven Price
Mr Brian William Proops
Mr Russell Proudfoot
Mr John Matthew
Puckeridge
Mr Michael John
Puckeridge
Mr Martin George
Puckeridge
Mr Russell George
Puckeridge
Mr Bradley Puckeridge
Mr Christopher Quinnell
Mr Kenneth Edward
Radford
Mr Michael Raptis
Mr Michael Reaiche
Mr Steve Reardon
Mr Scott Redford
Mr Hakija Redzovic
Mr Robert Relf
Mr Bernard John Rigby
Mr Arthur Neville Rizk
Mr Tony Rizk
Mr James Roach
Mr Jordan Roach
Mr William John Robards
Mr Geoff Robinson
Mr Christopher Rogaris
Ms Pamela Rogaris
Mr Leslie Thomas Rolls
Mr Peter Rose
Ms Marie Gladys Ross
Ms Angela Rossi
Mr Kenneth Graham Rowan
Mr Brett Rowe
Mr Michael Rowe
Ms Mavis Rowe
Mr Colin Rowe
Mr Michael Ryan
Mr Ron Ryan
Mr Kevin Ryan
Mr Paul James Said
Mr Vincent Samuel
Mr Anthony Samuel
Mr Greg Sankey
Mr Joe Sartor
Ms Lynne Schutjes
Mr Alan Schwebel
Mr Michael Secomb
Mr Joe Semrani
Mr Scott Seward
Mr Warren Sharman
Mr Matthew Shorrock
Mr Laz Simeonidis
Mr Robert John Simpson
Mr John Patrick Simpson
Ms Anne Sinclair
Mr Michael Joseph Sleba
Mr Stephen Mark Small
Mr Stephen Small
Mr Anthony Richard Smart
Mr Kevin Smee
Mr Michael Smith
Mr Joshua Smith
Ms Carol Smith
Mr Kenneth Smith
Mr Barry Smith
Mr Phillip Lindsay Smith
Mr William John Smith
Mr Robert Snoch
Mr Larry George
Sondergard
Mr Peter John Speirs
Mr Raymond Spiteri
Mr Martin Spiteri
Mr Stanley Stanton
Mr Sandy Steuerwald
Mr Gavin Stevenson
Mr John Stewart
Mr Klaus Dieter Stoecker
Mr Robert John Stone
Mr Patrick Sullivan
Mr Stewart Swales
Mr Gregory John Swiderski
Mr Darryle Taber
Mr Pierre Tabet
Mr Ray Taylor
Mr Bernie Temple
Mr Edward John Thick
Mr Norm Thomas
Mr Raymond Stanley
Thompson
Mr Paul Tilbury
Mr Dean Anthony Tiller
Mr Dallas William Tiller
Mr John Edward Tindale
Mr John William Tindale
Ms Debra Joy Tinker
Mr Trevor Charles
Townsend
Mr Robert Trevan
Mr Mario Tritsiniotis
Mr Michael Tsiattalos
Ms Klery Tsiattalos
Mr Adrian Turner
Mr Troy Tycehurst
Mr Paul Tycehurst
Mr George Steven Valiotis
Mr Jamie Valk
Mr Robert Francis Valk
Ms Sharon Varcoe
Mr Pasquale (Peter) Vartuli
Mr Leslie Raymond Vincent
Mr Alan Vincin
Mr Nick Vlahos
Mr Raymond Herbert Voget
Mr Peter Wagstaff
Mr Greg Wakeford
Mr Colin Walker
Mr Stephen Want
Mr Barry Ward
Mr Richard Ward
Mr Peter Watsford
Mr Charles Peter Wesley
Mr Frederick Wheatley
Ms Barbara White
Mr Zac White
Mr Joshua White
Mr Darcy White
Mr Lloyd Wesley White
Mr Cecil Ralph Whiteman
Mr Peter Whitney
Mr Nathan Wilcox
Mr Matthew Richard Wilcox
Mr Kevin Wilcox
Mr John Wild
Mr Jason Williams
Mr John Charles Williams
Mr Daniel Williams
Mr Peter John Williams
Mr Bob Williams
Mr Peter Robert Williamson
Mr Robert Williamson
Mr Peter Winchester
Mr Donald William Wray
Mr Robert Ernest Wyatt
Mr Shane Michael Wyatt
Mr Russell Anthony Yates
Mr David Yazbeck
Mr Robert Yazbeck
Mr Paul Zada
Mr Angelo Zafiris
Mr John Zafiris
Mr Jerald Joseph Zarb
Mr Richard Zogbee
Mr Sean Zreik
Mr Garth Zreik
Mr Allan Zreik

 

[Captain Kickass]

Nice work ! Some interesting names there.

In response to original question : Hell NO !!!

 

[RobDog55er]

So you would exclude Steve Price from voting? The man is a life member of the football club.

 

[Hammer]

that's not the complete list tbh

 

[D0ggyStylz]

I do not know where you got that list from but it is not a full list. My name should be on that list.

Perhaps it isn't because it is my first year of voting (that list might be of members who had voting rights last year and prior).

This would be Masons first year as a voting member. He would not be able to vote being a player, but would as a former player.

HTH

 

[Paulina..]

where'd u find that list??

 

[Paulina..]

i think steve price should be allowed 2 as he'll always have the best interests at heart for the club even though he doesn't play for us anymore..

 

[TCB-BD]

I think if you've served the club for more than 10 years or more... you deserve to.. as much as I hate to say it, by then, you've done enough service to the club in most cases that you deserve that right...

I think though that every case should be judged by merit, if you leave in the way Willie did, it's questionable as to whether you deserve to have a vote, but if you wanting to be a part of the club and forced to go due to the salary cap...then you should still be allowed to have your say.

Not sure if that makes any sense at all, but that's my opinion.

 

[RobDog55er]

they print the voting members list in every annual report

 

[TCB-BD]

they print the voting members list in every annual report

As most organisations do...but yeah I am guessing quite a few new members have been added to that list in the past year, who will be voting tomorrow.

 

[RobDog55er]

most likely..... i'll be there tomorrow, there's going to be a lot of media attention there as well.

 

[d_eye]

ex players that have left their club on a sour note, are always going to use their vote in a negative way towards their old club.

Answer to original Question = No.

 

[D0ggyStylz]

they print the voting members list in every annual report

That would be last years list. You will find Willies name in the next report

 

[..shurrup..]

thats a tough one....when i look at players like steve price i think yeah they should but when you look at mason, i think they shouldnt

 

[Bakes]

No way ex players should have any say at all

 

[The Dominator]

I dont have a problem with ex players, but ex players currently playing for or working for another club????? Well thats a no brainer.

 

[rwalker999]

Good onya Buster

Anyone that uses the c word is a poor excuse of a bloke I reckon.

Regards,
Russell