Official Round 3 - Dogs vs Tigers - Consolidated Match Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.

Spoonman84

Kennel Immortal
Premium Member
Joined
Oct 1, 2013
Messages
17,736
Reaction score
31,795
One concern I have about this win was the nature of our tries... none resulted from a crisp set play / through the hands and might even be considered a bit fortuitous.

Not that it really matters how we score them.
There was a few nice plays were we created numbers on the edges but just didn't finish it off.

With so many changes there was always going to be a bit of clunkiness that will gel with more game time.
 

EB18

Kennel Enthusiast
Joined
Aug 7, 2017
Messages
1,699
Reaction score
1,708
That ill-disciplined period between 60-65 mins — where Holland (stupidly) got penalised for 4th tackle strip when Tigers were going nowhere, Lichaa forced an unnecessary pass for a knock-on and Lewis kicked out on the full trying to bend it like Beckham — wouldn’t go unpunished by better opposition. I hope Pay bakes them for this in the video session.
Great post dude absolutely spot on. I was filthy watching these. Pay better roast them. Lewis needs to be better in managing the game at the end. These mistakes are unacceptable. Especially that stupid pass from lichaa after we did a shitload of def.
 

TwinTurbo

Kennel Legend
Gilded
Joined
Oct 22, 2018
Messages
9,422
Reaction score
15,616
You don’t think Lewis had some shocking kicks and last tackle options? That 40/20 attempt that went dead can be a game changer.
Couldn't blame him too much for that, the wind was inconsistent, sometimes howling. He corrected for it, kicked with lower trajectory to minimise the wind effect. Some of his bombs were spot on landing 1-2 metres out from their line, not easy in those conditions. The 80 metre drop out was Brentnall like (that'll get the memories stirring).

Go Dogs
 

Howard Moon

Kennel Addict
2 x Gilded
Premium Member
Joined
Apr 24, 2018
Messages
6,568
Reaction score
3,445
So to be a negative nancy.

The changes some of us wanted were finally made (Martin in, JJ to lock, sacking montoya, Ogden on). Hence I'm concerned about how Pay can't see the obvious.

2nd, our team looked a lot more fresh and given that Maguire is known for an elite fitness of his teams, we matched it with the tigers. But also us looking a lot more fresh this game compared to the last two, does this give credence to the rumour that pay was flogging our team on the captains run for the first two rounds? If so again it's a negative mark on Pay.
Nobody was calling for Okunbor and not many for Meaney to take the 1, and they were two of our best
 

The Innovator

Kennel Enthusiast
Joined
Nov 5, 2016
Messages
1,482
Reaction score
1,139
Nice win boys, lets just embrace the win. Napa man of the match !
His best match for some time. He’s an enforcer. That’s why he’s an Origin player. He has a presence on the field that makes opponents very nervous. He’s also got rid of the shit in his game.
 

dogwhisperer

Kennel Addict
Joined
Sep 5, 2016
Messages
7,305
Reaction score
14,151
One concern I have about this win was the nature of our tries... none resulted from a crisp set play / through the hands and might even be considered a bit fortuitous.

Not that it really matters how we score them.
Did you see Melbourne's trys on the weekend?
You make your own luck in Rugby League champ
 

Spoonman84

Kennel Immortal
Premium Member
Joined
Oct 1, 2013
Messages
17,736
Reaction score
31,795
Couldn't blame him too much for that, the wind was inconsistent, sometimes howling. He corrected for it, kicked with lower trajectory to minimise the wind effect. Some of his bombs were spot on landing 1-2 metres out from their line, not easy in those conditions. The 80 metre drop out was Brentnall like (that'll get the memories stirring).

Go Dogs
It wasn't just that kick there was also the kick out on the full. He was just sloppy in a few things I'm sure it will sorted during the week.
 

dogluva

Kennel Immortal
Joined
Nov 23, 2007
Messages
17,686
Reaction score
8,338
Wow! I have just watched a replay of the game as I was unable to view it live yesterday as we were in Sydney at a function. We were at least able to hear some of the game on the radio and from the commentary provided there the Tigers were shit and that is why we won. What a lot of rot!

Watching the game and listening to it on the radio were worlds apart; no credit to us at all and they kept raving on about the wind being so strong that we had a distinct advantage first half. Well it also worked against us with a couple of the Princes kicks being pretty ordinary but then again what about the drop out that went well into Tigers territory? Sister in law was at the game and she said it was nothing out of the ordinary for an afternoon at Campbelltown living just down the road from the stadium. She has seen it all before....

Mr Pay and the boys did a really great job yesterday to at least for a while shut up some the negative nellies who parade as the media. I am buoyed by the efforts of yesterday and I have that feeling of anticipation and excitement once again for the boys in the blue and white. No, I am not getting ahead of myself here but I had a distinct rush of pride in knowing that this squad does have it in them to play some great attacking footy and also muscle up in defence. We hurt the Tigers yesterday not only on the score board in the way of points but in the tackles we put on...several of them bell ringers and you could actually HEAR the hits. They played as a team and for each other and yes even for us fans...What has happened in one short week to turn things around to a more positive aspect?...the coach re-signing, the players being dropped, the shit that we as fans have thrown their way ( and the Fox team made mention of that too when they stated that we DEMANDED the reinstatement of Rhys Martin to the team) ...to my mind a combination of all of these things. Now the message is clear....you will play first grade if you perform and it is solely up to you to keep your spot just as it is the responsibility of those dropped to perform well enough to be in line for a recall. I know that people really don't want to read this but if it had been a certain other recent coach of the Dogs we would still be watching the same old , same old running around.


I was so proud of the boys for finally standing up and being counted. Jacko in the middle was superb and the edge forward CHN played brilliantly. What about the hit by Ofahiki on Farrah which left him in a world of hurt; that was worth the price of admission alone. Playing Martin in the run on squad for Elliot was a master stroke but Adam did not disappoint when he came on. Jayden...well young man stand up and take a bow. I made the comment prior to this game that he needed to make this one count and boy did he! Finally a glimpse of his potential that has the club keen to keep him in the blue and white. His height was a distinct advantage for us and he constantly made post contact metres in attack. Defence needs a bit of work still, but Rome was not built in a day.
Meaney, well what can one say. He reminds me quite a bit of the General in the way he sniffs around the back picking up the dregs and saving our bacon on a few occasions with some last ditch defensive efforts grounding the ball in goal and just generally cleaning up. I thought that JMK lifted immensely and had some nice work from dummy half and a few probing runs in broken play. Our halves were steady and controlling and finally Foran showed some glimpses of the form that had him rated as a half of note.

Let me say that each and every one of those guys out there yesterday put in and from all reports were very attentive to the Dogs fans during and after the game. AND...... the team song.. I watched it closely and the emotions displayed by EVERY player, new and old alike and THE COACH were spine tingling..watch it and be moved just like I was...

https://www.bulldogs.com.au/news/2019/03/31/round-3-the-dogs-are-havin-a-party/

Stats sometimes can be misleading but ours were pretty good from yesterday although we need to rein in the missed tackles and errors plus the penalties conceded ( but several of those were dodgy ones yesterday)

https://www.nrl.com/draw/nrl-premiership/2019/round-3/wests-tigers-v-bulldogs/

This is only one game and I know that the boys will need to lift again next week as we face the Storm but gee if it is the start of something special for us this year we could be in for a rip roarer against the premiership fore runners.

The "myth" played a shocker and was the lucky recipient of a dubious call from the officials when he blatantly knocked on from a kick. We may have been paying part of his contract but I think his efforts yesterday and in some of their other games has vindicated the decision made to move him on. In saying he played poorly we did not allow him to play any other way....
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top