POLL : Available Coaches and Coaching Records - Choose your poison.

Which coach would you like

  • Shane Flanagan

    Votes: 118 53.6%
  • Josh Morris

    Votes: 13 5.9%
  • Cameron Ciraldo

    Votes: 21 9.5%
  • Paul Green

    Votes: 4 1.8%
  • ASSASSIN

    Votes: 37 16.8%
  • Other.....

    Votes: 26 11.8%
  • Grunthos

    Votes: 1 0.5%

  • Total voters
    220

Dogs Of War

On the Warpath
Joined
Sep 2, 2003
Messages
2,110
Reaction score
1,737
I like data. Data makes things easier to see clearly. So here are the season by season coaching records for each available coach who is worth mentioning. You can click on the seasons in the data to show you how the year played out.

Shane Flanagan.



Pepitide Ban

NRL 20156thSemi Final14100469476Shane FLANAGAN16
-​
Valentine HOLMES164
-​
Michael GORDONRemondis Stadium11,926
NRL 20163rdPremiers1761580404Shane FLANAGAN19
-​
Valentine HOLMES219
-​
James MALONEYSouthern Cross14,579
NRL 20175thQualifying Final1590476407Shane FLANAGAN13
-​
Sosaia FEKI161
-​
James MALONEYSouthern Cross12,953
NRL 20184thPrelim Final1680519423Shane FLANAGAN22
-​
Valentine HOLMES148
-​
Chad TOWNSENDSouthern Cross12,700

Emailing players during his suspension ban.

I like this record. He took over a very poor Ricky Stuart coached team, and year by year built them up. Note the Sharks won a wooden spoon in the years he wasn't coaching them (2014)

Overall Record

FLANAGAN, Shane1965-12-022010-13, 2015-1818610282254.8


Josh Morris


RL 20197thQualifying Final12120514464John MORRIS15
-​
Josh MORRIS102
-​
Shaun JOHNSONPointsbet12,224
NRL 20208thQualifying Final10100480480John MORRIS16
-​
Sione KATOA120
-​
Shaun JOHNSONNetstrata* 2,454
NRL 20219th10140520556John MORRIS, Josh HANNAY14
-​
Connor TRACEY, William KENNEDY88
-​
Braydon TRINDALLNetstrata* 5,970

Took over Shanes' team. They played well, but were never a real contender. And then spat the dummy cause they were looking for other coaches cause even the Sharks realised they were headed on a downwards spiral. A no in my book

Overall Record


MORRIS, John1980-07-292019-21512427-47.1

Paul Green



NRL 20145thSemi Final14100596406Paul GREEN15
-​
Antonio WINTERSTEIN234
-​
Johnathan THURSTON1300SMILES16,114
NRL 20153rdPremiers1770587454Paul GREEN16
-​
Antonio WINTERSTEIN208
-​
Johnathan THURSTON1300SMILES17,009
NRL 20164thPrelim Final1590584355Paul GREEN15
-​
Kyle FELDT201
-​
Johnathan THURSTON1300SMILES17,728
NRL 20178thRunners Up13110467443Paul GREEN15
-​
Kyle FELDT102
-​
Ethan LOWE1300SMILES16,528
NRL 201813th8160449521Paul GREEN14
-​
Kyle FELDT166
-​
Johnathan THURSTON1300SMILES15,417
NRL 201914th9150378500Paul GREEN11
-​
Kyle FELDT86
-​
Jordan KAHU1300SMILES13,658
NRL 202014th5150368520Paul GREEN, Josh HANNAY19
-​
Kyle FELDT122
-​
Kyle FELDTQLD Country Bank* 8,390

THis data doesn't tell the full story. Neil Henry had been coaching the Cowboys and had that team in the semi's each year for the past 3 years. After taking them from bottom of the table. Paul Green was able to put the icing on top. But when he needed to rebuild the team after Thurston left, well the stats tell the story.

Overall Record

GREEN, Paul1972-09-122014-201688880-52.4List


Cameron Ciraldo



Only coached the 8 games. Taking a red hot Panthers from 4th to 6th on the table.

Overall Record
Penrith2018844050.0%


ASSASSIN

One of the Kennel's own. Highly regarded junior coach with over 40 wins and 3 losses to his name. Able to identify junior talent and communications with supporters will be at an all time high due to the frequency of his postings on the Kennel. I have heard rumours that team list Tuesday will be picked via a poll on this very website and submitted directly to the NRL.

Untested at NRL level.


Other....


As the name suggests, anyone else you think you should get a go. They would want to have a pretty damn record in NSW Cup/QLD Cup/ESL

Some of those who people like to throw around

Shane Wane
Wigan2012-1826818379668.3%

Kristian Woolf (Also coached 2 games for Newcastle with one win and one loss)
St Helens2020-22524012076.9%List

Geoff Toovey

Manly2012-151156450155.7%

Walker Brothers (though Ben left, so only Chris is left coaching Ipswich now).

Never finished below 8th on the table. That said, there are only 14 teams. So 8th isn't always good.

Grunthos

Grunthos, a seasoned coach, has shown interest in taking command of the floundering bulldog's team.
He has 20+ years as a rugby and league coach from minis to seniors at school and local club level, and his teams have appeared in five grand finals and won three and his graded teams have NEVER missed a finals series and he believes he has the plan to bring the mighty dogs back to grand-final contention!
As well-credentialed as coach Grunthos is, he won't come cheap, weighing up some surprising six-figure offers from other top-ranked League and Rugby teams both here and abroad all clamouring for his services.
Gus Gould had better have deep pockets to snag the maestro!
 
Last edited:

ILiveForDib

Kennel Addict
Joined
Aug 11, 2016
Messages
6,910
Reaction score
5,977
I like data. Data makes things easier to see clearly. So here are the season by season coaching records for each available coach who is worth mentioning. You can click on the seasons in the data to show you how the year played out.

Shane Flanagan.



Pepitide Ban

NRL 20156thSemi Final14100469476Shane FLANAGAN16
-​
Valentine HOLMES164
-​
Michael GORDONRemondis Stadium11,926
NRL 20163rdPremiers1761580404Shane FLANAGAN19
-​
Valentine HOLMES219
-​
James MALONEYSouthern Cross14,579
NRL 20175thQualifying Final1590476407Shane FLANAGAN13
-​
Sosaia FEKI161
-​
James MALONEYSouthern Cross12,953
NRL 20184thPrelim Final1680519423Shane FLANAGAN22
-​
Valentine HOLMES148
-​
Chad TOWNSENDSouthern Cross12,700

Emailing players during his suspension ban.

I like this record. He took over a very poor Ricky Stuart coached team, and year by year built them up. Note the Sharks won a wooden spoon in the years he wasn't coaching them (2014)

Overall Record

FLANAGAN, Shane1965-12-022010-13, 2015-1818610282254.8


Josh Morris


RL 20197thQualifying Final12120514464John MORRIS15
-​
Josh MORRIS102
-​
Shaun JOHNSONPointsbet12,224
NRL 20208thQualifying Final10100480480John MORRIS16
-​
Sione KATOA120
-​
Shaun JOHNSONNetstrata* 2,454
NRL 20219th10140520556John MORRIS, Josh HANNAY14
-​
Connor TRACEY, William KENNEDY88
-​
Braydon TRINDALLNetstrata* 5,970

Took over Shanes' team. They played well, but were never a real contender. And then spat the dummy cause they were looking for other coaches cause even the Sharks realised they were headed on a downwards spiral. A no in my book

Overall Record


MORRIS, John1980-07-292019-21512427-47.1

Paul Green



NRL 20145thSemi Final14100596406Paul GREEN15
-​
Antonio WINTERSTEIN234
-​
Johnathan THURSTON1300SMILES16,114
NRL 20153rdPremiers1770587454Paul GREEN16
-​
Antonio WINTERSTEIN208
-​
Johnathan THURSTON1300SMILES17,009
NRL 20164thPrelim Final1590584355Paul GREEN15
-​
Kyle FELDT201
-​
Johnathan THURSTON1300SMILES17,728
NRL 20178thRunners Up13110467443Paul GREEN15
-​
Kyle FELDT102
-​
Ethan LOWE1300SMILES16,528
NRL 201813th8160449521Paul GREEN14
-​
Kyle FELDT166
-​
Johnathan THURSTON1300SMILES15,417
NRL 201914th9150378500Paul GREEN11
-​
Kyle FELDT86
-​
Jordan KAHU1300SMILES13,658
NRL 202014th5150368520Paul GREEN, Josh HANNAY19
-​
Kyle FELDT122
-​
Kyle FELDTQLD Country Bank* 8,390

THis data doesn't tell the full story. Neil Henry had been coaching the Cowboys and had that team in the semi's each year for the past 3 years. After taking them from bottom of the table. Paul Green was able to put the icing on top. But when he needed to rebuild the team after Thurston left, well the stats tell the story.

Overall Record

GREEN, Paul1972-09-122014-201688880-52.4List


Cameron Ciraldo



Only coached the 8 games. Taking a red hot Panthers from 4th to 6th on the table.

Overall Record
Penrith2018844050.0%


ASSASSIN

One of the Kennel's own. Highly regarded junior coach with over 40 wins and 3 losses to his name. Able to identify junior talent and communications with supporters will be at an all time high due to the frequency of his postings on the Kennel. I have heard rumours that team list Tuesday will be picked via a poll on this very website and submitted directly to the NRL.

Untested at NRL level.


Other....


As the name suggests, anyone else you think you should get a go. They would want to have a pretty damn record in NSW Cup/QLD Cup/ESL

Some of those who people like to throw around

Shane Wane
Wigan2012-1826818379668.3%

Kristian Woolf (Also coached 2 games for Newcastle with one win and one loss)
St Helens2020-22524012076.9%List

Walker Brothers (though Ben left, so only Chris is left coaching Ipswich now).

Never finished below 8th on the table. That said, there are only 14 teams. So 8th isn't always good.
Shane Flanagan has the best record, most experience won a premiership and is an actual coach who has proved himself.
 

foREVerA7X

Kennel Established
Joined
Jan 5, 2020
Messages
668
Reaction score
839
As I stated on another thread, given the state of the club and players performance and amount of plodders we have, hiring an untested and unproven coach (ie Ciraldo) would be even more detrimental to the club.

We NEED a proven NRL Standard coach and only option is Flange Snr.

A rookie coach is only viable if a club is already in a good space both financially and performance and the Sharks are a good example of this. Good roster who performed relatively ok over the past few years so they added Fitzgibbon whose fresh approach has worked.

Neil Henry is very Meh for me, atleast Flange Snr had a reason he wasn't allowed to coach, albeit a wrong reason so you have to ask, why hasn't Henry got another gig yet?
 

Doge

Kennel Established
Joined
Jan 7, 2022
Messages
959
Reaction score
1,671
As I stated on another thread, given the state of the club and players performance and amount of plodders we have, hiring an untested and unproven coach (ie Ciraldo) would be even more detrimental to the club.

We NEED a proven NRL Standard coach and only option is Flange Snr.

A rookie coach is only viable if a club is already in a good space both financially and performance and the Sharks are a good example of this. Good roster who performed relatively ok over the past few years so they added Fitzgibbon whose fresh approach has worked.

Neil Henry is very Meh for me, atleast Flange Snr had a reason he wasn't allowed to coach, albeit a wrong reason so you have to ask, why hasn't Henry got another gig yet?
We NEED a proven NRL standard halfback, if we sign Flange Snr what are we going to do about Flange Jnr?
 

Dogs Of War

On the Warpath
Joined
Sep 2, 2003
Messages
2,110
Reaction score
1,737
We NEED a proven NRL standard halfback, if we sign Flange Snr what are we going to do about Flange Jnr?
You can see via his record, that he builds a team. So if his kid isn't the answer, he will get rid of him. It's last chance saloon for him.
 

Shanked

U been Shanked
Joined
May 22, 2008
Messages
11,561
Reaction score
2,604
Just another pommy wanker. I will need to talk to the Australian Government and get you deported. Or even better spend some time on Christmas Island.
i'm sure you'll be taken seriously...
 

CQDog

Kennel Legend
Premium Member
Ladder Champion
Joined
Nov 29, 2020
Messages
10,261
Reaction score
13,328
Shane Flanagan would be great if his son wasn’t here :/ John Morris should coach us if we are aiming for the experienced nrl coach and Cameron ciraldo should be aimed for the rookie head coaching role.
 
Top