Wahesh
The Forefather of The Kennel
- Joined
- Dec 6, 2007
- Messages
- 24,859
- Reaction score
- 12,192
Our Biggest Dud Signings in the Last 10 Years
Yes, I know, there's no point in dwelling on the past, what's done is done, but some people are looking for answers and/or wanting to know where things went wrong, let's discuss dissect and discuss them.
1. Keiran Foran. He was on somewhere between $1,000,000 and $1,200,000 per season, and never played out a full season. You would expect someone on that kind of money to be a marquee player, but Keiran had absolutely no impact on the team, and we missed the finals every year he was with us. Now if we take aside his injuries, and look at what else happened. He was expecting to take a paycut from the Bulldogs given how much he earned and how little he played, yet he was still no happy with our offer. Many other players would've jumped at the offer we made him, but it wasn't good enough.
Greedy, injury-prone, and not willing to repay the club for the trust they placed in him - far and away the worst.
2. Tony Williams. Good old T-Rex. He set the world on fire in his earlier years at Parramatta and then Manly. Tony managed to play 80 games for us, but never made any kind of impact. Big for nothing like a Charlie Leano MkII, this guy did nothing for the club in attack or defense. He managed to play 5 games for Cronulla before being released, joining Parramatta, and playing 1 game. He is now, for obvious reasons, a free agent.
3. Aaron Woods. It still baffles me how this dud has played for New South Wales and even Australia. He is a plodder of the highest order. He plays games and isn't very injury prone, but he is NOT a game changer, and not the kind of forward that people have faith in. He's a player that just makes up the numbers and I have no idea what Des Hasler saw in him. I would've been happier signing one of Sims brothers instead of this hack.
4. Dylan Napa. Big Papi? This bloke was a big tool. It's not mystery that as soon as he signs with us, a sex video of him is released. Then on the field, the ranga made absolutely no impact whatsoever. He won a Premiership with the Roosters in 2018 thanks to being behind a team that was, in every way, over the salary cap. He comes to a club that needs all the help it can get, and does nothing. He hasn't received a contract yet for 2022 (surprise surprise), and it's not looking hopeful. How he played for Queensland is... well... anyone's guess.
5. Drury Low and Moses Mbye. We have a tie for 5th place shared by 2 duds.
Drury Low: while Ben Barba missed out the start to the 2013 season, Drury Low stepped in. He couldn't take or do anything you require a fullback to do. He had some speed, but he could never play to put it to good use. The best result he could do for us was 2 tries in one game (playing on the wing, mind you, and being put into space), but didn't do much else after playing a total of 9 games. It's no wonder why he couldn't secure a contract with another NRL club after his contract with us expired in 2014. He is currently playing Group 6 Rugby League for the Narellan Jets.
Moses Mbye: While he debut with us, he showed some good promise at playing five-eighth or hooker, but whatever craze that was disappeared pretty quickly. He then was re-signing for a further 2 years at something probably close to a million a season, and played fullback. Here, there were some good signs. Again, it disappeared pretty quickly, and the kind of talking himself up was released by Dean Pay. I'm gobsmacked he actually managed to play for Queensland in State of Origin - however I'm glad he did because that trip he took in 2019 effectively handed NSW the series.
Out of these duds TWO of them have signed with St. George-Illawarra - Aaron Woods and Moses Mbye. Goodluck Dragons, you'll need it. I expect a long 2022 ahead for them.
Yes, I know, there's no point in dwelling on the past, what's done is done, but some people are looking for answers and/or wanting to know where things went wrong, let's discuss dissect and discuss them.
1. Keiran Foran. He was on somewhere between $1,000,000 and $1,200,000 per season, and never played out a full season. You would expect someone on that kind of money to be a marquee player, but Keiran had absolutely no impact on the team, and we missed the finals every year he was with us. Now if we take aside his injuries, and look at what else happened. He was expecting to take a paycut from the Bulldogs given how much he earned and how little he played, yet he was still no happy with our offer. Many other players would've jumped at the offer we made him, but it wasn't good enough.
Greedy, injury-prone, and not willing to repay the club for the trust they placed in him - far and away the worst.
2. Tony Williams. Good old T-Rex. He set the world on fire in his earlier years at Parramatta and then Manly. Tony managed to play 80 games for us, but never made any kind of impact. Big for nothing like a Charlie Leano MkII, this guy did nothing for the club in attack or defense. He managed to play 5 games for Cronulla before being released, joining Parramatta, and playing 1 game. He is now, for obvious reasons, a free agent.
3. Aaron Woods. It still baffles me how this dud has played for New South Wales and even Australia. He is a plodder of the highest order. He plays games and isn't very injury prone, but he is NOT a game changer, and not the kind of forward that people have faith in. He's a player that just makes up the numbers and I have no idea what Des Hasler saw in him. I would've been happier signing one of Sims brothers instead of this hack.
4. Dylan Napa. Big Papi? This bloke was a big tool. It's not mystery that as soon as he signs with us, a sex video of him is released. Then on the field, the ranga made absolutely no impact whatsoever. He won a Premiership with the Roosters in 2018 thanks to being behind a team that was, in every way, over the salary cap. He comes to a club that needs all the help it can get, and does nothing. He hasn't received a contract yet for 2022 (surprise surprise), and it's not looking hopeful. How he played for Queensland is... well... anyone's guess.
5. Drury Low and Moses Mbye. We have a tie for 5th place shared by 2 duds.
Drury Low: while Ben Barba missed out the start to the 2013 season, Drury Low stepped in. He couldn't take or do anything you require a fullback to do. He had some speed, but he could never play to put it to good use. The best result he could do for us was 2 tries in one game (playing on the wing, mind you, and being put into space), but didn't do much else after playing a total of 9 games. It's no wonder why he couldn't secure a contract with another NRL club after his contract with us expired in 2014. He is currently playing Group 6 Rugby League for the Narellan Jets.
Moses Mbye: While he debut with us, he showed some good promise at playing five-eighth or hooker, but whatever craze that was disappeared pretty quickly. He then was re-signing for a further 2 years at something probably close to a million a season, and played fullback. Here, there were some good signs. Again, it disappeared pretty quickly, and the kind of talking himself up was released by Dean Pay. I'm gobsmacked he actually managed to play for Queensland in State of Origin - however I'm glad he did because that trip he took in 2019 effectively handed NSW the series.
Out of these duds TWO of them have signed with St. George-Illawarra - Aaron Woods and Moses Mbye. Goodluck Dragons, you'll need it. I expect a long 2022 ahead for them.
