Opinion Offer topine to Storm for loan for B smith?

[Bulldog wazza]

Risky business... Topine needs to be our top retention similar to when we had young guns Jacko and Dale coming through under The Beast Tank and Bobcat...
Hence my thoughts would be to bring back Dale next year here to mentor him

 

[bullanth]

Phark the storm, they can keep the fat lard, give them no one.
Dietz and Jmk ok with me, we need a fullback and 2 props

Haven’t seen enough of deitz,but I’ve seen enough of jmk to know that he’s not the solution.

 

[kungfuman]

Grant was always gonna be a star. There’s the X Factor and then there’s the IT Factor and Grant has IT.

Does he do computer repairs?

 

[DinkumDog]

They cant have everything go their way all the time... we gave them reimis... they did the same thing with grant

We didn’t ‘give’ them anyone Alzz. We released Reimis and he happened to be picked up by the Storm. There was no other part of the transaction. It’s that simple.

 

[gee333]

Heres an idea, offer topine an extension on his contract and then offer him to melbourne as loan for B smith for a year or 2 and then he can go there and become a star and then come back here
Imagine the experience he will gain

The same could happen with grant going to tigers and become a star in a year and then returned to melbourne

I would prefer him to be playing with us... I think he would fall in love with the system down there and not wanna come back..

 

[Big Owl]

They want like for like. Lock or 2nd rower.

Then please make them take Adam Idiot

 

[ASSASSIN]

Then please make them take Adam Idiot

Unfortunately, Bellamy has a brain...

 

[LordSidious66]

Phark the storm, they can keep the fat lard, give them no one.
Dietz and Jmk ok with me, we need a fullback and 2 props

Prefer Topine over JMK.