Monty ruled out for six weeks?

LeeroyJenkins said:
He did have the most carries but his runs were kinda meh. Without Kiraz we're kinda cooked. Broncos absolutely destroyed us in yardage.
Click to expand...
I felt Tuala was low down the list of our issues last week. He outperformed Monty easily IMO. I looked up stats and he had the most metres. 179 metres is a solid effort.
 
Brendan7 said:
I'd be saying the same thing win or loss last week, the move was dumb it created needless errors and it wasn't needed said it at the time. Burton is needed at 6, heck Galvin should be in reserve grade where we aren't moving all our spine to fit the guy in weekly.

Last week there was some justification for it, not this week
Click to expand...
I know what you mean, but it wasnt the worst lineup by CC.

Personally i think Galvin has to be in the halves for us to have the best chance in the finals. He's easily the best ball-player, but just needs to settle down and be selective with his passes. He looks under pressure to prove himself.

The more games he plays before finals, the better for us it will be.

Most likely, he will take Sextons spot.
 
Rinakama aint being picked, he's only 19 and will potentially play the first finals game. There's no chance Ciraldo debuts him imo and even if he did you lot on here would throw him under the bus the minute he makes a poor defensive read. Wing is a difficult defensive position, considering this I'm comfortable with Tuala or Wilson to replace him. And judging by Ciraldo's praise last week, I think it will be Tuala, he insinuated he was going to start over Montoya prior to his ankle injury.
 
Nate DAWG said:
I felt Tuala was low down the list of our issues last week. He outperformed Monty easily IMO. I looked up stats and he had the most metres. 179 metres is a solid effort.
Click to expand...
I dont doubt the stats, but on the eye test, Montoya seemed to do better with his runs that Tuala.

I barely noticed Tuala TBH and when i did, he looked likevhe was getting smashed in hit-ups.
 
Nate DAWG said:
100% Kiraz and Crittas are brothers and have the combination and instinct. Samoans always looking out for the Lebos lol
Click to expand...
They would have to be the best combo in the league.
 
Marki said:
I know what you mean, but it wasnt the worst lineup by CC.

Personally i think Galvin has to be in the halves for us to have the best chance in the finals. He's easily the best ball-player, but just needs to settle down and be selective with his passes. He looks under pressure to prove himself.

The more games he plays before finals, the better for us it will be.

Most likely, he will take Sextons spot.
Click to expand...

He can do all of that next season. I'm not against the guy, what I am against is him being gifted games, us having to upheave our whole side and system one that was despite some issues top of the ladder at the time.

Galvin has to prove he's more than a 1 game in 5 player and that's at best, that is what he was at the Tigers people forget the other games where he was awful.

We are not winning changing the spine during game, Galvin to NSW Cup to work with Woods.
 
Nate DAWG said:
I felt Tuala was low down the list of our issues last week. He outperformed Monty easily IMO. I looked up stats and he had the most metres. 179 metres is a solid effort.
Click to expand...
Don't let the truth get in the way of a good story.......
 
Doggies 04 said:
I'd rather have Wilson I know he rushes in alot but he has the speed to finish of trys
Click to expand...

Every time Wilson rushes up to no one I end up hate eating a kebab with the lot. I was pushing 150kg and finally dropped some weight since he's been out of the team this season. For my arteries sake, please God, no.
 
SARGE said:
Because he is a Knights reject.
Click to expand...
Maybe its time to give sua another go.
He seems the one with most potential.
Alot of boys on here rate him.
We need one of these young guys to make that position their own.
 
Big loss in all honesty.

Leave Xerri in centres, fast track Mazzone so we have fastest bloke on field out wide. No chance kicking in behind him.

Can't do any worse than the other turnstile options, but at least gives us insane speed. Not to mention chatting down anyone that breaks the line.

Sizewise he's bulked up a bit, but still young (hence paying Flegg).

But can we pay him if outside to 30, and not on Development Contract.?
 
hoges said:
i have been montoyas biggest critic and if in a few weeks that it is obvious how much we miss him ill be the first person to put my hand up and say we need him. I have serious doubts that will happen. but ill definitely do it.
Click to expand...
100%.no one here hates Montoya but if we had a young winger coming through that was a gun and had x factor ,Montoya wouldn't be getting his position back after his injury.
Hes solid but he just isn't that good .
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top