As with all things Salary Cap related, the key is a mix, players on the way up, players at their peak, players on the way down, relatively inexperienced players, mixed with seasoned veterans. Players that come up through our juniors, players from other teams that were trapped and couldn’t use their talents, players that were grossly underpaid for their abilities, internationals from other countries, etc. A look at the long term successful teams and that’s what we see, a mixture of ingredients that the coaching staff mould into a team.
As for your examples, seriously, SBW had a dickhead in each ear telling him what to do and blocking out everything else. He had a valid contract, with years to run, and in order to escape from that he fled the country, snuck out like a thief in the night. No amount of “smarter” was going to prevent that. JT is 100% hindsight, no one could predict the future for him, we had 2 quality players well ahead of him at the time in Sherwin (who should have won the DM over AJohns) and Anasta (who at that time had played for Australia and was a current SOO player). Sometimes the timing just isn’t right, no matter how “smart“ you play it at the time.
Go Dogs