I didnt say any experts said he was an incredible talent. But they do mention the qualities in his game along with his flaws, which is something the kennel experts can't do. They are impartial and express their opinions as such.
I dont think he is a star either, but he is a great defender and has a good long boot on him. People will argue he never finds grass on these long kicks, but that is factually incorrect. In any case, there is no one else in our halves who can kick as far as he does, and given how many mistakes we make, and how often we are locked in our own half, this is an asset to the team, hence his selection.
What am suggesting though, is thT like it or not, lewis is on our books next year, so if by some incredible coaching breakthrough lewis can be trained to be a good attacking half we will benefit massively, because not only will we have a solid attacking half, he will also be the best defensive half in the game.
If you can't grasp my point or just want to keep arguing it, then that's on you. I have shared my views and don't feel the need to have to explain it further. Your also entitled to your opinion.