Lachlan Lewis - Consolidated Thread

[Apercots]

1 Bmoz
6 Jackson
7 Lewis
9 JMK
14 Holland

 

[Dogna88]

Lewis is not first grade standard dogs to lose by 30

As oppsed to losing by 28?

 

[Howard Moon]

You know our season is bad when we're arguing over who is worse out of Frawley and JMK

 

[CrittaMagic69]

Frawley has had more than enough of an opportunity to shine this year.. you backed Frawley and he has flopped hard, so your cut, what a surprise .. he does not deserve to be in first grade ever again. he provides even less than JMK in attack .. every time frawley kicks the ball its almost a guaranteed 7 tackle set for the opposition.. and I'm not even going t start on his defence, because ill be here all day.

I backed Frawley and i'm cut? Hahahaha. fucking hell you Pay fanboys talk absolute fucking shit, just constantly making up shit and twisting things to suit your pro Pay agenda.

I never wanted Frawley to play firstgrade for us again and said so all pre season, but Pay was the one that backed him and said he was going to be our 6. He spent all pre season there and as a result he is the only one left that has any sort of chemistry and is contributing to tries in some sort of way.

You do realise Frawley has played almost half as many games as JMK but has 3 times as many total try involvements, 7 times as many combined line breaks and line break assists and forced more drop outs. So where is this better attack you speak from JMK? Heck JMK has been there for 14 games and HASN'T MADE A SINGLE LINE BREAK FFS.

They're both not good enough, but Frawley is clearly a much better option in the halves than JMK. JMK in actual fact is probably the worst half i have ever seen, just completely useless in basically every aspect of the game other than tackling. But hey, continue to twist facts and talk some more shit to try and defend your mate Pay.

 

[GDR]

I backed Frawley and i'm cut? Hahahaha. fucking hell you Pay fanboys talk absolute fucking shit, just constantly making up shit and twisting things to suit your pro Pay agenda.

I never wanted Frawley to play firstgrade for us again and said so all pre season, but Pay was the one that backed him and said he was going to be our 6. He spent all pre season there and as a result he is the only one left that has any sort of chemistry and is contributing to tries in some sort of way.

You do realise Frawley has played almost half as many games as JMK but has 3 times as many total try involvements, 7 times as many combined line breaks and line break assists and forced more drop outs. So where is this better attack you speak from JMK? Heck JMK has been there for 14 games and HASN'T MADE A SINGLE LINE BREAK FFS.

They're both not good enough, but Frawley is clearly a much better option in the halves than JMK. JMK in actual fact is probably the worst half i have ever seen, just completely useless in basically every aspect of the game other than tackling. But hey, continue to twist facts and talk some more shit to try and defend your mate Pay.

They are both as bad as each other in attack... but one is far superior in defence ... easy choice if you ask me ..

 

[Horny Wog]

If Lewis doesnt come up trumps like King Wally this weekend, not one God will save the kid from the kennel cauldron

 

[CrittaMagic69]

They are both as bad as each other in attack... but one is far superior in defence ... easy choice if you ask me ..

They clearly aren't as bad as each other in attack, you're just ignoring clear facts.

 

[GDR]

They clearly aren't as bad as each other in attack, you're just ignoring clear facts.

You clearly ignoring the fact of who the dominant half is in the attacking zones..

If you factoring in all the terrible last tackle attempts by Frawley , youll probably find that the ratio is pretty terrible.. JMK generally is not the go to person .. So yeah frawley has made heaps more attempts on the last so hes bound to have more try assists..

 

[CrittaMagic69]

You clearly ignoring the fact of who the dominant half is in the attacking zones..

If you factoring in all the terrible last tackle attempts by Frawley , youll probably find that the ratio is pretty terrible.. JMK generally is not the go to person .. So yeah frawley has made heaps more attempts on the last so hes bound to have more try assists..

More dribble, just absolute fucking bullshit. 14 games, 14 fucking games and not a single line break and only 1 line break assist for JMK yet you reach for every excuse possible to justify this bullshit. Frawley is clearly the better half option, you're just flat out wrong.

 

[Horny Wog]

I would take Dane Chisholm over any half currently at our club

 

[GA45]

I backed Frawley and i'm cut? Hahahaha. fucking hell you Pay fanboys talk absolute fucking shit, just constantly making up shit and twisting things to suit your pro Pay agenda.

I never wanted Frawley to play firstgrade for us again and said so all pre season, but Pay was the one that backed him and said he was going to be our 6. He spent all pre season there and as a result he is the only one left that has any sort of chemistry and is contributing to tries in some sort of way.

You do realise Frawley has played almost half as many games as JMK but has 3 times as many total try involvements, 7 times as many combined line breaks and line break assists and forced more drop outs. So where is this better attack you speak from JMK? Heck JMK has been there for 14 games and HASN'T MADE A SINGLE LINE BREAK FFS.

They're both not good enough, but Frawley is clearly a much better option in the halves than JMK. JMK in actual fact is probably the worst half i have ever seen, just completely useless in basically every aspect of the game other than tackling. But hey, continue to twist facts and talk some more shit to try and defend your mate Pay.

So you are up Pay for having to select between shit and shit. Yep it’s all the coaches fault.

 

[dogwhisperer]

More dribble, just absolute fucking bullshit. 14 games, 14 fucking games and not a single line break and only 1 line break assist for JMK yet you reach for every excuse possible to justify this bullshit. Frawley is clearly the better half option, you're just flat out wrong.

I wouldn't have any of them in FG to be honest.
At the moment Frawley is our best attacking half in the whole squad, but what he does good in attack is negated because of his terrible defence.
JMK is straight out not a half. May become a good footy player with more experiance but who knows.
I would of had Brown in FG for the whole year. Brown over Lichaa any day of the week.

 

[CrittaMagic69]

I wouldn't have any of them in FG to be honest.
At the moment Frawley is our best attacking half in the whole squad, but what he does good in attack is negated because of his terrible defence.
JMK is straight out not a half. May become a good footy player with more experiance but who knows.
I would of had Brown in FG for the whole year. Brown over Lichaa any day of the week.

And i wouldn't either. JMK only has value as a utility at this stage as he's fast and reasonably good in defence. Brown should have always been there on the bench and then starting once Lichaa flopped, but Pay didn't like him and shafted him to reserve grade.

 

[GDR]

More dribble, just absolute fucking bullshit. 14 games, 14 fucking games and not a single line break and only 1 line break assist for JMK yet you reach for every excuse possible to justify this bullshit. Frawley is clearly the better half option, you're just flat out wrong.

You see only what you wanna see and then you carry on like its gospel, but yet you call me the dribbler ?? LOL all good man, I was looking for an intelligent discussion, but clearly engaged the wrong member..

 

[CrittaMagic69]

You see only what you wanna see and then you carry on like its gospel, but yet you call me the dribbler ?? LOL all good man, I was looking for an intelligent discussion, but clearly engaged the wrong member..

Garbage, the evidence fully suppports what i see and absolutely nothing supports your point.

 

[GDR]

Garbage, the evidence fully suppports what i see and absolutely nothing supports your point.

I watch games, I don't watch spreadsheets...

"Not every that counts can be counted, Not everything that can be counted counts" Albert Einstein

Without even looking at a single stat, most fair minded people will tell you 2 things..
1. neither JMK or frawleys attack is up to NRL standards
2. Frawleys defence is not up to NRL standards

 

[Mr Invisible]

Totally right about JMK not having any support play. I would put him on the bench, just because of lack of numbers.
I would give Cleeland a go. Hes not rubbish as some have said. He would step up in FG.

Cleelands defence is worse than Frawleys, and he is prone to brain explosions. He also picks and chooses when to get involved and rarely gets sighted in the final 40 of games.

There are good reasons the club don't view a future with him, and that he hasn't played first grade with any club yet.

He’s had player of the year awards in ISP/NSW Cup hasn’t he?

I think he’s stepped up in reserve grade but not sure he could cut first grade to be honest

Cleeland always had someone decent alongside him in the halves making him look better than what he actually is.

Fair call he's a ball runner, but that's all he does.

 

[dogwhisperer]

Cleelands defence is worse than Frawleys, and he is prone to brain explosions. He also picks and chooses when to get involved and rarely gets sighted in the final 40 of games.

There are good reasons the club don't view a future with him, and that he hasn't played first grade with any club yet.


Cleeland always had someone decent alongside him in the halves making him look better than what he actually is.

Fair call he's a ball runner, but that's all he does.

They all look better in reserve grade until they make the switch to First Grade.

 

[Horse]

They clearly aren't as bad as each other in attack, you're just ignoring clear facts.

Mate you bombarded the kennel with your typical 500+ posts repeating yourself about how Frawley shouldn't have been dropped. Whether or not he chalked a couple of try assists in the stats column it's obvious to see he's nowhere near first grade standard.

Can't pass, can't kick, can't organise, can't defend. Pay was right to drop him then and now that he's got an extra half at his disposal in Lewis, he'll be right to drop him again.

Just cop yet another L on the chin and move on you goose

 

[CrittaMagic69]

I watch games, I don't watch spreadsheets...

"Not every that counts can be counted, Not everything that can be counted counts" Albert Einstein

Without even looking at a single stat, most fair minded people will tell you 2 things..
1. neither JMK or frawleys attack is up to NRL standards
2. Frawleys defence is not up to NRL standards

What an absolute load of dribble from you, complete garbage. I fucking blew your argument to pieces from the beginning and yet you're still trying to constantly spin shit. Now your making points i have already made and trying to pull them off as your own, just laughable.