Is Sione Katoa the worst hooker to play for the bulldogs.

[CBDoggies]

Like the rest he is average at best. No vision, a good kick or 2 in him but very bad in defensive reads on the line. We got split in half up the guts a few times with his lazy defence. (That could also be the 1% stuff good teams do which a lot of players didn’t bother with in 21)

 

[dogwhisperer]

To answer the question of this thread: YES

 

[adamsapple]

I'll say no only because there was never any hype around him
We got rid of ennis for lichaa and no one complained we thought we got the better deal between us and sharks
Katoa was always in a crap doggies team so he will always look worse
Lichaa was in a half decent dogs team and still sucked
So to answer the thread yes katoa sucked
But lichaa is the worst 9 we've had

 

[Phalangist]

I'll say no only because there was never any hype around him
We got rid of ennis for lichaa and no one complained we thought we got the better deal between us and sharks
Katoa was always in a crap doggies team so he will always look worse
Lichaa was in a half decent dogs team and still sucked
So to answer the thread yes katoa sucked
But lichaa is the worst 9 we've had

you have changed the question to get that answer

 

[Phalangist]

jmk is on par with katoa to be honest

 

[Dingo]

I'd rather him than Lichshit. Lichshit was the worst thing that happened to us at hooker.

 

[Yougra]

Katoa is the worst.

At least Lichaa was good defensively

I still have bad memories of watching breaks against us through the ruck last season and the replays showing Katoa throwing out a lazy arm as his attempted tackle. No committment or desperation

Very lazy player who was lucky to play as many NRL games as he has. So happy that we have moved on from those types of players

 

[Nate DAWG]

Katoa was a minimum wage player who played like a minimum wage player. Not sure what people expected. Not sure the purpose of the thread.

 

[Family Guy]

LOL why the fuck is this thread still open? He's moved on so who gives a fuck anymore.

Maybe we should start a thread about Flanno being the worst 7 to play for us....he'd be in the top 3 for sure

 

[Marki]

I'll say no only because there was never any hype around him
We got rid of ennis for lichaa and no one complained we thought we got the better deal between us and sharks
Katoa was always in a crap doggies team so he will always look worse
Lichaa was in a half decent dogs team and still sucked
So to answer the thread yes katoa sucked
But lichaa is the worst 9 we've had

Yep Lichaa was next level rubbish.
The fact it took so long for Des to figure this out makes him equally pathetic.

 

[Cook]

Des never coached Lichaa to suit he’s game but. Just wanted a tackling machine

 

[ILiveForDib]

LOL why the fuck is this thread still open? He's moved on so who gives a fuck anymore.

Maybe we should start a thread about Flanno being the worst 7 to play for us....he'd be in the top 3 for sure

Top 3 is generous only contender is the one game Chase Stanley play halfback and even then I would prefer him on a wheel chair half a bottle of scotch down.

 

[mez]

Hey guys it's me fox,

Sorry for being away for a while but I have had to deal with some personal issues.

After watching tonightd battle I wanted to her everyone's opinion if you users do agree that this young chap is the worst to put the 9 on.

After deep discussion with fellow comrades we agree but a few other names got thrown into the mix but after much healthy debate a joint vote came through for him .

Thoughts and opinions and don't forget to like and reply to dis post.

Yes

 

[kap123]

LOL why the fuck is this thread still open? He's moved on so who gives a fuck anymore.

Maybe we should start a thread about Flanno being the worst 7 to play for us....he'd be in the top 3 for sure

Hahaha geez that is harsh. Flanno wasn't good but I've had to sit through plodders like Dan Holdsworth, Arana Taumata, Chase Stanley, Lachlan Lewis pull the 7 jersey on and I'm a fairly young fan. I'd say there'd be some turd pre 2000.

With regards to Katoa, he is by far the worst I've ever watched. Service was horrendous, no kicking game (despite the odd flukey 40/20), lazy and abysmal defensively.

 

[berries1935]

Please delete thread.... who cares

 

[Family Guy]

Hahaha geez that is harsh. Flanno wasn't good but I've had to sit through plodders like Dan Holdsworth, Arana Taumata, Chase Stanley, Lachlan Lewis pull the 7 jersey on and I'm a fairly young fan. I'd say there'd be some turd pre 2000.

With regards to Katoa, he is by far the worst I've ever watched. Service was horrendous, no kicking game (despite the odd flukey 40/20), lazy and abysmal defensively.

Mate I've managed to successfully block out the lean years so I honestly can't remember all the duds we've had in the 7 jersey...that's why I thought I'd be conservative and say top 3 but you may be right. Let's just say top 10 to be safe.

In saying that, I'd put Lewis ahead of Flanno by a country mile...and I don't rate Lewis at all

 

[Bob dog]

Lichaa was a good defender, heard the Knights are looking for a hooker.

 

[DinkumDog]

Liccha had good hands until he put them through a window courtesy of Herb and the former Mrs. Liccha. Oh wait - no his hands were rubbish before that .