Buzz Rothfield’s top 50

[Mozzie]

This is really a matter of opinion. Get 50 so called experts and other than Cam Smith and both JT's the lists would look a lot different. FFS it is hard enough to get the kennellers to agree on our best 17 players

 

[Freakzilla]

Wade graham’s Better than josh Jackson, now ?

He is better. Offers way more in attack. Love Josh Jackson though.

 

[Bad Billy]

He is better. Offers way more in attack. Love Josh Jackson though.

Wade graham is the forward version of josh Reynolds.
Tries really hard but is clearly clumsy and receives most of his praise through pity.

 

[Freakzilla]

Wade graham is the forward version of josh Reynolds.
Tries really hard but is clearly clumsy and receives most of his praise through pity.

Lol, you must not watch any Sharks games because Wade is an excellent player.

 

[Bad Billy]

Lol, you must not watch any Sharks games because Wade is an excellent player.

Sadly, due to being a shift worker on a shift with only sharks fans, I watch nearly all sharks games.
He’s an excellent trier, but an average player.

 

[Moedogg]

Boyd Cordner in the top 10? Ive never seen him single handedly influence a game. Top. 10 should be reserved for those type of players......James Graham in his prime made the top 5 a couple of years ago.

 

[Freakzilla]

Sadly, due to being a shift worker on a shift with only sharks fans, I watch nearly all sharks games.
He’s an excellent trier, but an average player.

Wow, if you think he is an average player then you have no idea.

 

[Emdog85]

Wade graham is the forward version of josh Reynolds.
Tries really hard but is clearly clumsy and receives most of his praise through pity.

And here he goes again. Mr know it all

 

[Brizdog]

Mitchell Pearce is higher than Greg Inglis and RTS. Not only pissed but needs to put down the crack pipe.

 

[Freakzilla]

Mitchell Pearce is higher than Greg Inglis and RTS. Not only pissed but needs to put down the crack pipe.

Inglis and RTS have done nothing the last 2 years. They have both been a waste of money.

 

[GUSLER]

Klem and Jacko are top 20 if not top 10 - over Hasler. Injury free foran is top 7

 

[GUSLER]

Australian front row and back rower. We have a Good platform. Lichaa and forand and mbyr could take us next level. We probably need one more creative player though

 

[GA45]

How are we near the salary cap limit ?

Fuck you des

 

[Brizdog]

Inglis and RTS have done nothing the last 2 years. They have both been a waste of money.

Yes I simply don’t rate Mitchell Pearce. I would rather have Rts and Inglis over him any day. I think he is the most overrated player in the league. His origin record speaks for itself.

 

[Freakzilla]

Yes I simply don’t rate Mitchell Pearce. I would rather have Rts and Inglis over him any day. I think he is the most overrated player in the league. His origin record speaks for itself.

He is crap at Origin level but really good at NRL level. At least he has won games for his team the last 2 years. Inglis doesn't play and RTS went to kill his career at the Warriors.

 

[Flanagun]

Why are we still talking about this drunkard's shit list? I wouldn't trust Buzz to compile his own shopping list....

 

[Brizdog]

He is crap at Origin level but really good at NRL level. At least he has won games for his team the last 2 years. Inglis doesn't play and RTS went to kill his career at the Warriors.

Last two years shouldn't count. This list should be current meaning now, both RTS and Inglis are fit and I would have them over Pearce.

 

[Freakzilla]

Last two years shouldn't count. This list should be current meaning now, both RTS and Inglis are fit and I would have them over Pearce.

His top 50 is based on performances. Off course the last 2 years count. You can't just assume RTS is going to play good now after 2 years of crap.

 

[Brizdog]

His top 50 is based on performances. Off course the last 2 years count. You can't just assume RTS is going to play good now after 2 years of crap.

Yes i agree he should be top 50, but top 20 I think not. You can't assume he will play well now but based on talent and past experience he is a more valuable player. Yes the last two years should count which included two failed origin campaigns, after 7 attempts. Also last two years he has failed to steer his salary cap rorting team in the GF.

 

[Freakzilla]

Yes i agree he should be top 50, but top 20 I think not. You can't assume he will play well now but based on talent and past experience he is a more valuable player. Yes the last two years should count which included two failed origin campaigns, after 7 attempts. Also last two years he has failed to steer his salary cap rorting team in the GF.

Pretty sure this is based on just NRL level not rep.