News Barrett sacking a double-edged sword as Dogs face big unknown in new era: Brutal Review

djdeep4172

Kennel Enthusiast
Joined
Sep 29, 2014
Messages
3,705
Reaction score
6,983
Another year, another emotional rollercoaster.

The arrivals of Josh Addo-Carr and Matt Burton were meant to turn the Bulldogs around and catapult them from wooden spooners to finals contenders.

A two-point win over the Cowboys in Round 1 put the smile back on captain Josh Jackson’s face and gave fans the most dangerous weapon to start a season with — hope.

Six straight losses followed and that hope quickly faded... until a stunning upset over the Roosters delivered shades of the early 2000s.

But the Bulldogs faithful were brought back to reality when things took a turn. The writing was on the wall for coach Trent Barrett, who vanished so quickly it was almost fitting that his final game was in ‘Magic’ Round.

And then the Mick Potter era began.

With no more speculation hanging over the coach’s head, the shackles came off and the Eels thrashing became a turning point of the season. All of a sudden the Dogs became ‘the entertainers’. Until they weren’t.

A couple of heavy losses to the Warriors and the Eels were a timely reminder that there’s still a lot of work to do but the Dogs deservedly finished the year on a high with their best player, Matt Burton sealing the game with a 78th minute field goal.

BULLDOGS END OF SEASON REVIEW

2022 Record: W7 L17, 29.2% win rate

Season grade: D

What went right: Matt Burton and Mick Potter.

When the Bulldogs signed Matt Burton on $500,000 a season there were a few warranted concerns. He had lived up to the hype at Penrith, sure, but in the centres — not the position the Dogs signed him to play.

Burton was the Bulldogs’ best and most important player this season, playing every minute of every game. He made his State of Origin debut, albeit in the centres, and his boot even terrified the most seasoned fullbacks.

In hindsight, $500,000 was actually a bargain.

Mick Potter can also hold his head up high after stepping mid-season and transforming the Bulldogs’ attack.

Potter wasn’t anywhere near the NRL squad prior to Round 11. He was coaching Mounties in New South Wales Cup, which was a feeder side to the Bulldogs but was made up of almost all part-time players.

But his fresh set of eyes did wonders for the club and had many calling for him to officially be given the head coaching job.

Jacob Kiraz deserves an honourable mention too. Kiraz backed himself to walk away from a top 30 deal with the Knights to join the Bulldogs on a train-and-trial. It worked a treat as he nailed down a spot on the wing and earned a two-year extension.

What went wrong: Trent Barrett.

There was so much hope when the man lauded for Penrith’s attack joined the Bulldogs, only for the club to receive the wooden spoon in his maiden season.

Barrett was given a bit of time to soothe those first-season teething problems but GM of football Phil Gould eventually ran out of patience after the Bulldogs found themselves at the bottom of the table once again after 10 rounds.

Barrett’s exit has ended up being a double-edged sword. The results ever since prove that it was the right call, but it was also a step back in the seemingly never-ending rebuild.

The Dogs went after another Penrith assistant in Cameron Ciraldo and have locked him in on a five-year deal. A lot is riding on the Ciraldo appointment because the club can’t afford to go through yet another coach.

What they need: Pre-season to start now.

Several new pieces to the puzzle will arrive to Belmore in the off-season, but there’s still a big question mark over whether they’ll all fit into place.

Aside from a new face at the helm, Reed Mahoney and Viliame Kikau are among the 2023 additions. On paper, that’s an exciting prospect. But it’s going to take time for them to fit into their new system seamlessly — particularly Mahoney who will leave one of the more experienced spines at Parramatta to join one that is still figuring itself out.

In the perfect world, the Dogs could dive straight into preparation for 2023, but depending on finals, all three signings could be preoccupied until October. Throw in the World Cup, which Kikau will be a part of, and it could be a bit of a frantic pre-season.
 

TwinTurbo

Kennel Legend
Gilded
Joined
Oct 22, 2018
Messages
9,481
Reaction score
15,760
Aside from a new face at the helm, Reed Mahoney and Viliame Kikau are among the 2023 additions. On paper, that’s an exciting prospect. But it’s going to take time for them to fit into their new system seamlessly — particularly Mahoney who will leave one of the more experienced spines at Parramatta to join one that is still figuring itself out.
Kikau should fit straight in, played with Burton many times and has Ciraldo as Coach continuity. In fact he should fit in better and faster than most.

Always a Bulldog
 

albatross

Kennel Enthusiast
Joined
Feb 3, 2017
Messages
2,266
Reaction score
2,686
Another year, another emotional rollercoaster.

The arrivals of Josh Addo-Carr and Matt Burton were meant to turn the Bulldogs around and catapult them from wooden spooners to finals contenders.

A two-point win over the Cowboys in Round 1 put the smile back on captain Josh Jackson’s face and gave fans the most dangerous weapon to start a season with — hope.

Six straight losses followed and that hope quickly faded... until a stunning upset over the Roosters delivered shades of the early 2000s.

But the Bulldogs faithful were brought back to reality when things took a turn. The writing was on the wall for coach Trent Barrett, who vanished so quickly it was almost fitting that his final game was in ‘Magic’ Round.

And then the Mick Potter era began.

With no more speculation hanging over the coach’s head, the shackles came off and the Eels thrashing became a turning point of the season. All of a sudden the Dogs became ‘the entertainers’. Until they weren’t.

A couple of heavy losses to the Warriors and the Eels were a timely reminder that there’s still a lot of work to do but the Dogs deservedly finished the year on a high with their best player, Matt Burton sealing the game with a 78th minute field goal.

BULLDOGS END OF SEASON REVIEW

2022 Record: W7 L17, 29.2% win rate

Season grade: D

What went right: Matt Burton and Mick Potter.

When the Bulldogs signed Matt Burton on $500,000 a season there were a few warranted concerns. He had lived up to the hype at Penrith, sure, but in the centres — not the position the Dogs signed him to play.

Burton was the Bulldogs’ best and most important player this season, playing every minute of every game. He made his State of Origin debut, albeit in the centres, and his boot even terrified the most seasoned fullbacks.

In hindsight, $500,000 was actually a bargain.

Mick Potter can also hold his head up high after stepping mid-season and transforming the Bulldogs’ attack.

Potter wasn’t anywhere near the NRL squad prior to Round 11. He was coaching Mounties in New South Wales Cup, which was a feeder side to the Bulldogs but was made up of almost all part-time players.

But his fresh set of eyes did wonders for the club and had many calling for him to officially be given the head coaching job.

Jacob Kiraz deserves an honourable mention too. Kiraz backed himself to walk away from a top 30 deal with the Knights to join the Bulldogs on a train-and-trial. It worked a treat as he nailed down a spot on the wing and earned a two-year extension.

What went wrong: Trent Barrett.

There was so much hope when the man lauded for Penrith’s attack joined the Bulldogs, only for the club to receive the wooden spoon in his maiden season.

Barrett was given a bit of time to soothe those first-season teething problems but GM of football Phil Gould eventually ran out of patience after the Bulldogs found themselves at the bottom of the table once again after 10 rounds.

Barrett’s exit has ended up being a double-edged sword. The results ever since prove that it was the right call, but it was also a step back in the seemingly never-ending rebuild.

The Dogs went after another Penrith assistant in Cameron Ciraldo and have locked him in on a five-year deal. A lot is riding on the Ciraldo appointment because the club can’t afford to go through yet another coach.

What they need: Pre-season to start now.

Several new pieces to the puzzle will arrive to Belmore in the off-season, but there’s still a big question mark over whether they’ll all fit into place.

Aside from a new face at the helm, Reed Mahoney and Viliame Kikau are among the 2023 additions. On paper, that’s an exciting prospect. But it’s going to take time for them to fit into their new system seamlessly — particularly Mahoney who will leave one of the more experienced spines at Parramatta to join one that is still figuring itself out.

In the perfect world, the Dogs could dive straight into preparation for 2023, but depending on finals, all three signings could be preoccupied until October. Throw in the World Cup, which Kikau will be a part of, and it could be a bit of a frantic pre-season.
The season was an F before Potter came! Probably a C- for his stint IMO.

It'll take a little while for most players to fully adapt to whatever attacking system Ciraldo brings, but it will be largely built around Mahoney and Kikau rather than them fitting into it. Mahoney will be pivotal to all our attack, especially if we don't find a half, and Kikau is a genuine strike weapon alongside Burton/JAC. We've also got great offload ability which will be better honed next year, but we rarely make anything of it. Mahoney's habit of staying alive in the play at all times will help us make a lot more of that weapon too.

Every team has off season disruptions but our job is to manage that well as business-as-usual and not see it as a problem. None of these problems are as big as our half and fullback gaps.
 

_G-Dog_

Kennel Legend
Joined
Apr 29, 2006
Messages
13,346
Reaction score
7,796
We are On the way up.. i can finally say that & confidently for the first time in ages..
 

Sword

Kennel Enthusiast
Joined
Aug 8, 2014
Messages
1,679
Reaction score
3,434
Potter showed thatTrent f@&ked this club in every way possible, (from the preseason),playing players out of position and ignoring the squads strengths and weaknesses with an imported irrelevant game plan. Ciraldo won’t make that mistake . We’re going to struggle without Vaughan in making metres when playing the top 8 sides, but I think we’ll win half of our games
 

Dognacious

Kennel Immortal
Staff member
Administrator
Premium Member
NF Draft Champion
Joined
Aug 4, 2007
Messages
23,614
Reaction score
11,085
Years ago Ciraldo took over from Barrett in the Penrith juniors as coach, took the club to a premiership in his first year, GF in the second too. They were not going well under Baz. History may repeat itself. Ciraldo turning a club around after replacing Baz who failed, has happened before.
 

Northern Beaches dog

Kennel Enthusiast
Joined
Feb 23, 2020
Messages
1,322
Reaction score
1,681
Kikau should fit straight in, played with Burton many times and has Ciraldo as Coach continuity. In fact he should fit in better and faster than most.

Always a Bulldog
Difference is, Burton played outside Kikau in Penrith.
It will be the opposite here.
Lets hope Burton works on his passing and creativity
 

D.O.W.

Kennel Addict
Joined
Mar 19, 2016
Messages
5,675
Reaction score
9,988
I sense there will be a decent signing by Nov1 or at the World Cup by Gus at 7 - hoping we’re pleasantly surprised…and no, I don’t have any oil, sauce or crystal balls.
 
Top