LordSidious66
Kennel Legend
- Joined
- Jul 30, 2011
- Messages
- 9,401
- Reaction score
- 6,282
I noticed Klein blew a penalty for us last night than overturned and gave the Warriors the scrum is he allowed to do that?
That's what I thought aswell. I was at the game with my uncle and both him and I and the guys we sit with were as astonished as both of us.Did not think they could tbh.
Yh im pretty sure through out the year i have heard the refs say to captains that it is to late to overturn the call as he blew a penaltyThat's what I thought aswell. I was at the game with my uncle and both him and I and the guys we sit with were as astonished as both of us.
they called a penalty first to the warrior player for not playing the ball, which made Reynolds quick tap it but they called it back after saying dogs knocked on first which meant there was no advantage taken by warriorsCan someone explain what actually happened?
Someone suggested the penalty was blown, Reynolds quick tap and then lost the ball so the ref said we took our advantage.
Others say (and I agree), the penalty was blown, Reynolds quick tape and then they called it back because they over turned the penalty call by saying we actually lost the ball first (before the voluntary tackle).
I thought it was for a voluntary tacklethey called a penalty first to the warrior player for not playing the ball, which made Reynolds quick tap it but they called it back after saying dogs knocked on first which meant there was no advantage taken by warriors
To be honest mate I watch all the 8 games every week and never seen a penalty over turned.They definitely overturn penalties sometimes. It happens when one ref blows the penalty, but then the other ref or video ref chimes in.
The decision was fine.The penalty was for not getting up and playing the ball as I saw it. Then Reynolds tapped and took off and was tackled by a Warriors player who was inside the 10metres and therefore off-side and so another penalty should have been awarded. The only explanation is that the referee changed his (their? who has control?) and ruled the original ball had been forced backwards by the dogs to the warriors player who was penalised and therefore no advantage so back for the scrum. Ridiculous. Once the decision is given for a penalty how can the advantage be relevant? Why is there no explanation given by the league.
Yes. The ref missed the initial knock on (somehow...) but cancelled the penalty afterwards once it was pointed out to him.Ok, we did knock on. The ref called it, that's fine. Then the ref blew a penalty because of an voluntary tackle. Knock on or not, a voluntary tackle is a voluntary tackle and therefore penalised. Did the touch judge or second referee, meters away, see something the ref, who made the call literally 2 feet away miss something they saw?