Opinion Top 10 halves from 2000 til present

[Kurrupt78]

Pretty self explanatory lol.

1. Andrew Johns

2. Jonathan Thurston

3. Darren Lockyer

4. Brad Fittler

5. James Maloney

6. Cooper Cronk

7. Stacey Jones

8. Brent Sherwin

9. Brett Kimmorley

10. Jason Taylor

Other mentions are Benji Marshall, Matty Orford, Mitchell Pearce, Preston Campbell, Braith Anasta and Trent Barrett

 

[TwinTurbo]

I'd rate Stacy Jones way higher than 7th, maybe 4th.

Go Dogs

 

[Spoonman84]

1. Joey
2. Thurston
3. Lockyer
4. Cronk
5. Freddie
6. Noddy
7. Jones
8. Benji
9. Maloney
10. Barrett

I loved Shifty but he didn't produce good footy long enough to be in my top 10. From 2002-2004 he was on top of his game but after that his form declined.

 

[Kurrupt78]

1. Joey
2. Thurston
3. Lockyer
4. Cronk
5. Freddie
6. Noddy
7. Jones
8. Benji
9. Maloney
10. Barrett

I loved Shifty but he didn't produce good footy long enough to be in my top 10. From 2002-2004 he was on top of his game but after that his form declined.

Yeah he wasn’t as consistent as the elite halves I agree

 

[Kurrupt78]

I'd rate Stacy Jones way higher than 7th, maybe 4th.

Go Dogs

Really?? If we go by stats then I have no clue who was better out of him or Freddy. I’ve just been a homer and named a list purely based on what I remember in more like a highlight reel.

 

[Freakzilla]

Pretty self explanatory lol.

1. Andrew Johns

2. Jonathan Thurston

3. Darren Lockyer

4. Brad Fittler

5. James Maloney

6. Cooper Cronk

7. Stacey Jones

8. Brent Sherwin

9. Brett Kimmorley

10. Jason Taylor

Other mentions are Benji Marshall, Matty Orford, Mitchell Pearce, Preston Campbell, Braith Anasta and Trent Barrett

Is this for everything they did since 2000 onwards or who was the best at their peak?

 

[Freakzilla]

1. Joey
2. Thurston
3. Lockyer
4. Cronk
5. Freddie
6. Noddy
7. Jones
8. Benji
9. Maloney
10. Barrett

I loved Shifty but he didn't produce good footy long enough to be in my top 10. From 2002-2004 he was on top of his game but after that his form declined.

Yeah he was the 2nd or 3rd best halfback in the game during that time but after 2004 he went backwards big time.

 

[Kurrupt78]

Is this for everything they did since 2000 onwards or who was the best at their peak?

A bit of both lol. Not leaning towards stats and that but what impression they left you as a fan in that time frame. Sorry, prob not as self explanatory as I thought. Lol

 

[Kurrupt78]

Is this for everything they did since 2000 onwards or who was the best at their peak?

More so from 2000 though. So last 20 years

 

[Kurrupt78]

Like for me, was Joey in 2005 in that state of origin. What he did that second game will be forever etched in my memory. He single handily destroyed QLD that night

 

[Freakzilla]

Like for me, was Joey in 2005 in that state of origin. What he did that second game will be forever etched in my memory. He single handily destroyed QLD that night

2nd and 3rd game. No other half could've done what he did that game. Thurston, Lockyer, Smith and Slater were powerless against him.

 

[Freakzilla]

I'm going to be different and pick the top 5 Halfbacks and top 5 five-eighths.

01. Andrew Johns
02. Jonathan Thurston
03. Cooper Cronk
04. Stacey Jones
05. Daly Cherry-Evans

01. Brad Fittler
02. Darren Lockyer
03. James Maloney
04. Benji Marshall
05. Keiran Foran

 

[Bulldogs09]

Think Scotty prince is up there too.

 

[Kurrupt78]

Think Scotty prince is up there too.

Was an integral part of that 2005 Tigers team

 

[Bulldogs09]

Was an integral part of that 2005 Tigers team

Was really good for tits too

 

[Freakzilla]

Scott Prince underrated also. Deserves a mention.

 

[Scoooby]

I'm going to be different and pick the top 5 Hlafbacks and top 5 five-eighths.

01. Andrew Johns
02. Jonathan Thurston
03. Cooper Cronk
04. Stacey Jones
05. Daly Cherry-Evans

01. Brad Fittler
02. Darren Lockyer
03. James Maloney
04. Benji Marshall
05. Keiran Foran

I like this list. Would have put the same names especially with five-eighths !!

 

[FaceBreaker]

Johns
Thurston
Cronk
Fittler
Lockyer

 

[bells76]

Daniel holdsworth
Ben ROBERTS
Joe Williams
Aaron Groom
Tony Williams
Arana tomatoe or what ever that flogs name was.
Lachlan Lewis

No others deserve to be mentioned.