Addo Carr

[Howard Moon]

Oh god lol.

Obviously another one who has skimmed over the fact that I was referring to the work in defence...

 

[CrittaMagic69]

Obviously another one who has skimmed over the fact that I was referring to the work in defence...

No I read exactly what you said, and yes it's still ridiculous. Slater was the absolute best in defence year in year out for a large period of time, meanwhile DWZ has played a few games at the back and is yet to play a single game at Billy's level. There is no comparison and there's absolutely no need to try and make one, some of you lose all logic when a player you like pops up.

 

[Howard Moon]

No I read exactly what you said, and yes it's still ridiculous. Slater was the absolute best in defence year in year out for a large period of time, meanwhile DWZ has played a few games at the back and is yet to play a single game at Billy's level. There is no comparison and there's absolutely no need to try and make one, some of you lose all logic when a player you like pops up.

Nothing wrong with giving credit where credit is due. He was a big factor in us going from the worst defensive team in the comp, to one of the better defensive teams. No need to get your panties in a knot

 

[kungfuman]

No I read exactly what you said, and yes it's still ridiculous. Slater was the absolute best in defence year in year out for a large period of time, meanwhile DWZ has played a few games at the back and is yet to play a single game at Billy's level. There is no comparison and there's absolutely no need to try and make one, some of you lose all logic when a player you like pops up.

Or in some cases a player someone hates then all logic does the same eh!

 

[CrittaMagic69]

Or in some cases a player someone hates then all logic does the same eh!

Who hates who?

 

[CrittaMagic69]

Nothing wrong with giving credit where credit is due. He was a big factor in us going from the worst defensive team in the comp, to one of the better defensive teams. No need to get your panties in a knot

No there isn't, but that doesn't mean you go and compare them to the GOAT lol.

 

[Howard Moon]

No there isn't, but that doesn't mean you go and compare them to the GOAT lol.

Not much more Billy could have provided on that side of the footy for a team who was previously copping weekly hidings.

 

[CrittaMagic69]

Not much more Billy could have provided on that side of the footy for a team who was previously copping weekly hidings.

IF YOU SAY SO.

 

[Howard Moon]

IF YOU SAY SO.

lol.. funny guy.... you going to offer anything of substance around here or just disagree with everything?

 

[CrittaMagic69]

lol.. funny guy.... you going to offer anything of substance around here or just disagree with everything?

There's nothing to add, i've already said what needs to be said but your minds set on thinking Billy couldn't do anything more than DWZ so whatever.

 

[JackDog]

Not much more Billy could have provided on that side of the footy for a team who was previously copping weekly hidings.

Including aerial Karate kicks to the head, shoulder charging players over the sideline, knees into try scorers, any other dirty shit that crossed his mind on the day...

 

[kungfuman]

Who hates who?

mmm, let me think lol.

 

[kungfuman]

Including aerial Karate kicks to the head, shoulder charging players over the sideline, knees into try scorers, any other dirty shit that crossed his mind on the day...

Don't forget forearms to the mouth !

 

[kungfuman]

Including aerial Karate kicks to the head, shoulder charging players over the sideline, knees into try scorers, any other dirty shit that crossed his mind on the day...

That kick was disgraceful shit and he had the hide to try and defend it.

 

[doggieaaron]

Jac now saying he’s staying at melb till end of year cleary a deal with whoever couldn’t be reached

 

[Sleeky]

Jac now saying he’s staying at melb till end of year cleary a deal with whoever couldn’t be reached

Standard day at the office I guess

 

[Howard Moon]

Jac now saying he’s staying at melb till end of year cleary a deal with whoever couldn’t be reached

more medical retirements required

 

[Sleeky]

more medical retirements required

More crafty management needed

 

[JackDog]

Jac now saying he’s staying at melb till end of year cleary a deal with whoever couldn’t be reached

Souffs must’ve run out of 2020 cap space...

 

[LordSidious66]

Jac now saying he’s staying at melb till end of year cleary a deal with whoever couldn’t be reached

So there is hope after all.