Opinion josh Reynolds Discussion Thread

[pupmichelle]

Haven't seen anyone name a source in a long time... I did it once a long time ago and caused me a fair bit of trouble

Bill is president of Sydney Olympic and is not associated directly with the Dogs, so take it with a grain of salt

 

[LordSidious66]

Information which has been passed onto me first hand by Bill Papas

If you don't mind me asking, who is Bill Papas?

 

[LordSidious66]

Bill is president of Sydney Olympic and is not associated directly with the Dogs, so take it with a grain of salt

Never mind, you answered my question.

 

[CrittaMagic69]

Unfortunately this looks to be happening, I'll cop it with Holbrook coming on board..

 

[Kempsey Dog]

Bill is president of Sydney Olympic and is not associated directly with the Dogs, so take it with a grain of salt

Ok fair enough. Can't say I'd be happy with the Reynolds and Lichaa news... good about the rest though

 

[vegny]

2020 Ins: Justin Holbrook (St Helens), Luke Thompson (St Helens), Josh Reynolds (West Tigers),
Joseph Manu (Sydney Roosters)

2020 outs: RFM (St George Illawarra), Danny Fualalo (Cronulla Sharks)

They wont be re-signing Fa'amanu Brown and John Olive.

Michael Lichaa will possibly be re-signed on a 1 year deal

Hope bill is well informed

 

[Blueandwhiteblood1968]

2020 Ins: Justin Holbrook (St Helens), Luke Thompson (St Helens), Josh Reynolds (West Tigers),
Joseph Manu (Sydney Roosters)

2020 outs: RFM (St George Illawarra), Danny Fualalo (Cronulla Sharks)

They wont be re-signing Fa'amanu Brown and John Olive.

Michael Lichaa will possibly be re-signed on a 1 year deal

I hope your wrong about Lichshit, he's still shit.

 

[Heckler]

2020 Ins: Justin Holbrook (St Helens), Luke Thompson (St Helens), Josh Reynolds (West Tigers),
Joseph Manu (Sydney Roosters)

2020 outs: RFM (St George Illawarra), Danny Fualalo (Cronulla Sharks)

They wont be re-signing Fa'amanu Brown and John Olive.

Michael Lichaa will possibly be re-signed on a 1 year deal

Joseph Manu? @dog whisperer??

 

[Scoooby]

As it comes along

Good one PAY..!!!

 

[bricktamland]

Save your breath, Gold Coast


NRL Leaks hears the Titans are wasting their time pursuing Justin Holbrook.

A very influential figure connected to the Bulldogs has been telling all and sundry the St Helens coach will be at Belmore next year.

Where that leaves Dean Pay remains to be seen, but it's ordinary form from the so-called Family Club.

https://www.sportingnews.com/au/lea...y-parramatta-eels/c92fslpi5pa61fnoef0o234l3/3

 

[The_Chimpster]

2020 Ins: Justin Holbrook (St Helens), Luke Thompson (St Helens), Josh Reynolds (West Tigers),
Joseph Manu (Sydney Roosters)

2020 outs: RFM (St George Illawarra), Danny Fualalo (Cronulla Sharks)

They wont be re-signing Fa'amanu Brown and John Olive.

Michael Lichaa will possibly be re-signed on a 1 year deal

I hope this is true (except for Reynolds and lichaa)

I don't see manu leaving the rooters tbh, but let's see what happens

 

[Chris Harding]

2020 Ins: Justin Holbrook (St Helens), Luke Thompson (St Helens), Josh Reynolds (West Tigers),
Joseph Manu (Sydney Roosters)

2020 outs: RFM (St George Illawarra), Danny Fualalo (Cronulla Sharks)

They wont be re-signing Fa'amanu Brown and John Olive.

Michael Lichaa will possibly be re-signed on a 1 year deal

Is this sourced, or just opinion?

 

[Mr. Ditkovich]

A backline of

1. DWZ
2. Okunbor
3. Hopoate / Harper
4. Manu
5. Smith

Has some potential.

But I’m not expecting anything until I see an official announcement.

 

[Snake]

Imagine for a moment Reynolds and Lewis in the halves together ... would make for an erratic and unpredictable but interesting game

 

[wendog33]

Save your breath, Gold Coast


NRL Leaks hears the Titans are wasting their time pursuing Justin Holbrook.

A very influential figure connected to the Bulldogs has been telling all and sundry the St Helens coach will be at Belmore next year.

Where that leaves Dean Pay remains to be seen, but it's ordinary form from the so-called Family Club.

https://www.sportingnews.com/au/lea...y-parramatta-eels/c92fslpi5pa61fnoef0o234l3/3

It's ordinary form that got us to this situation.

 

[086]

Renyolds on minimum coin would be worth it as a bench utility.
Lichaa on minimum to see if he can finally show his potential when he was a junior under a decent coach, otherwise GTFO!

 

[Riggs80]

Whilst I think Reynolds is better than most of the current side I wouldn’t sign him tbh
He has aged , he is injury prone these days , his best days have long gone , the club will have to pay half his currently salary as tigers wouldn’t pinch more and not worth it , his large salary plus playing Reggie’s affects tigers cap , that money freed could mean The tigers trump the dogs for a player or due to the extra cap space they force doggies to pay overs

The club should be signing players for the future or gun players that can offer the team something immediately, Reynolds is not skilful just an effort player , if playing with “effort” is contagious etc wouldn’t the plodder Elliott fill that role

 

[berries67]

Reynolds returning to the Bulldogs would not be a good idea. Sadly, I don't he has anything to offer. First, too many injury problems. Second, we need good organising halves which he has never been. Didn't he originally play hooker and Hasler turned him into a tackling machine playing in the halves ? Third having him around just to for his energy and club spirit - too much of a waste of salary cap space. Tigers say they would pay a portion but we need all we can get.
Given the recent injury history would any club in English Super League take him? 2 years in Tigers reserves - at least he would be paid but not really an ideal way to see out a NRL career which has seen the highs of Grand Finals and a State of Origin series win. However, he has achieved those 2 things which many NRL players will only get to dream about. Life doesn't give out fairy tale endings for everyone. It will be interesting to see where he ends up and I wish him all the best.

 

[bradyk]

Whilst I think Reynolds is better than most of the current side I wouldn’t sign him tbh
He has aged , he is injury prone these days , his best days have long gone , the club will have to pay half his currently salary as tigers wouldn’t pinch more and not worth it , his large salary plus playing Reggie’s affects tigers cap , that money freed could mean The tigers trump the dogs for a player or due to the extra cap space they force doggies to pay overs

The club should be signing players for the future or gun players that can offer the team something immediately, Reynolds is not skilful just an effort player , if playing with “effort” is contagious etc wouldn’t the plodder Elliott fill that role

According to ZT Reynolds is on 750k/y. If we paid 300k and Tigers paid 450k would you take him? We'd only have to pay more for him if other clubs come in with 350-400k (if he's not worth that then why would other clubs come in for him?). In theory he should mean more to us then other clubs, similar to Benji and Farah when they came back to the Tigers.

 

[the hound]

Hope bill is well informed

Joey Manu dropped from Roosters 17 for today's game. Coincidence?