TOLMAN @ 13, Good Move IMO

[dhoo8450]

I'd rather him start than come off the bench, but I'd also prefer someone with a bit of impact.

 

[doggieaaron]

I like tolman at 13 playing a stagg 80 min type role just tackle ,tackle ,tackle

 

[CrittaMagic69]

I like tolman at 13 playing a stagg 80 min type role just tackle ,tackle ,tackle

Name 1 other player in the NRL that does that. Bet you can't and for good reason.

 

[bowleggedwog]

Not this impact player or workhorse player garbage again, it doesn't exist in todays game. Tolman is just fucking shit in todays game.

We will agree to disagree on this one.

 

[Kiwipup]

Tolman is definitely not a impact bench play but is definitely a better starting lock than Elliott and Fulafel

 

[Dawain87]

Tolman at 13 for ISP

 

[Papa Joe]

Name 1 other player in the NRL that does that. Bet you can't and for good reason.

2017 Premiers Storm - Slade Griffin
2016 Premiers Sharks - Matt Prior
2015 Premiers Cowboys - Scott Bolton
2014 Premiers Souffs - Jason Clark
2013 Premiers Roosters - Luke O'Donnell
2012 Premiers Storm - Todd Lowrie
2011 Premiers Manly - Shane Rodney
2010 Premiers Dragons - Neville Costigan/Jarryd Saffy
2009 Premiers Storm - Dallas Johnson
2008 Premiers Manly - Mark Bryant
2007 Premiers Storm - Dallas Johnson
2006 Premiers Broncos - David Stagg
2005 Premiers Wests Tigers - Mark O'neil
2004 Premiers Bulldogs - TONY GRIMALDI

I rest my case!!!

 

[coach]

2017 Premiers Storm - Slade Griffin
2016 Premiers Sharks - Matt Prior
2015 Premiers Cowboys - Scott Bolton
2014 Premiers Souffs - Jason Clark
2013 Premiers Roosters - Luke O'Donnell
2012 Premiers Storm - Todd Lowrie
2011 Premiers Manly - Shane Rodney
2010 Premiers Dragons - Neville Costigan/Jarryd Saffy
2009 Premiers Storm - Dallas Johnson
2008 Premiers Manly - Mark Bryant
2007 Premiers Storm - Dallas Johnson
2006 Premiers Broncos - David Stagg
2005 Premiers Wests Tigers - Mark O'neil
2004 Premiers Bulldogs - TONY GRIMALDI

I rest my case!!!

Half them rarely played 80mins like gotenks asked......
Slade griffin
Matt prior
Scott Bolton
Jason clark
Todd lowrie
Shane Rodney
Mark Bryant
Very rarely played 80 mins

 

[CrittaMagic69]

2017 Premiers Storm - Slade Griffin
2016 Premiers Sharks - Matt Prior
2015 Premiers Cowboys - Scott Bolton
2014 Premiers Souffs - Jason Clark
2013 Premiers Roosters - Luke O'Donnell
2012 Premiers Storm - Todd Lowrie
2011 Premiers Manly - Shane Rodney
2010 Premiers Dragons - Neville Costigan/Jarryd Saffy
2009 Premiers Storm - Dallas Johnson
2008 Premiers Manly - Mark Bryant
2007 Premiers Storm - Dallas Johnson
2006 Premiers Broncos - David Stagg
2005 Premiers Wests Tigers - Mark O'neil
2004 Premiers Bulldogs - TONY GRIMALDI

I rest my case!!!

Are you joking me? There's no point going back as far as 2004 as you're working with 12 interchange vs 8 and pretty much none of the players you named played 80 minutes or just tackle all game. Not to mention i'm talking about in the NRL now. This is a terrible list and doesn't support your opinion at all.

 

[coach]

Are you joking me? There's no point going back as far as 2004 as you're working with 12 interchange vs 8 and pretty much none of the players you named played 80 minutes or just tackle all game. Not to mention i'm talking about in the NRL now. This is a terrible list and doesn't support your opinion at all.

Half rarely played 80 anyway mate, terrible list

 

[doggieaaron]

Name 1 other player in the NRL that does that. Bet you can't and for good reason.

Shaun fenson and thats without even looking and i believe the cowboys got to the gf last year thanks
Plus gavin cooper

 

[EB18]

Name 1 other player in the NRL that does that. Bet you can't and for good reason.

Probably Simon Mannering.

 

[coach]

Shaun fenson and thats without even looking and i believe the cowboys got to the gf last year thanks

Wasn't taumololo 13 bud? Lowe cooper
Backrow?
Pretty sure ur wrong
Fensom was lucky to be on the bench
Last time he had consistent game time was at the raiders

 

[CrittaMagic69]

Half rarely played 80 anyway mate, terrible list

Yup. Relevant players would be Jake Trbojevic, Mannering, Gallen or Burgess over the last few years. Why dis these players play 80? Because they can provide quality with abd without the vall for extended minutes, they're also not 1 dimensional. If they could only tackle they wouldn't be playing 80 and eating up valuable minutes lol.

 

[EB18]

Someone mentioned before the season started that he will change his lock almost weekly. Canberra do it regularly also. I dont understand this tactic, can someone explain it to me if they know?

 

[CrittaMagic69]

Shaun fenson and thats without even looking and i believe the cowboys got to the gf last year thanks
Plus gavin cooper

He definitely didn't start or play extended minutes. And Gavin Cooper is an edge forward lol.

 

[CrittaMagic69]

Probably Simon Mannering.

Yes. And Mannering can run a line, score a try, ball play or offload. If he couldn't do that would he have been playing 80? Nope.

 

[Dogna88]

Someone mentioned before the season started that he will change his lock almost weekly. Canberra do it regularly also. I dont understand this tactic, can someone explain it to me if they know?

Yeh its pretty simple if you think about it carefully and had a footy brain.

It's because he has no idea what to do and is panicking. Hopefully this works out this week. Lol

 

[flamebouyant]

We will agree to disagree on this one.

Its the only possible way with gotenks. You will always be wrong until you agree with him.

 

[CrittaMagic69]

Its the only possible way with gotenks. You will always be wrong until you agree with him.

Not true. Nobody can seem to come up with a sound argument to support their view and counter my argument. And if someone doesn't agree with me then they think i'm wrong and they're right? No?