The good faith part would be a issue still using that in this way wouldn't it? What would be considered good faith from the club using it this way?.......... if we have key injuries missing its ok, if we get 5th but the top 4 have record breaking points?
To me its a lazy clause anyway, I don't think the average fan would be happy if we got into 4th place doing the same thing next season, and then dropped out of the finals meekly. It fails to address any of the actual issues...... why not a percentage of players dropped from fg during the season should they not be hitting 100% of their kpi's (not 100% dropped in that situation because there is still the question of if there is someone in the lower grades actually plausibly better if given a shot), or promotion of lower level players to fg playing minutes to ensure we are developing depth, or set number of trys off set plays to ensure our play book is actually effective, or positive progression of set stats year on year, or the recruitment of 1 or more big signings (big to be defined in that clause, not later hyped as being big just to cross it off), one I'd like would be a goal on the average age of players per minute which would somewhat force the blooding of new players, and consideration of which senior players and strong seniors, and which are weak seniors that we carry to the detriment of our future squad (not to force a huge change to young players, just enough to ensure a good mix of age - experience to youth - hunger/longevity of career ahead........ I mean there are SOOOO many kpi's you could ask for that would be far more meaningful than make the top 4, I just made them up on the spot, why doesn't the board each come up with 100 of them, then pick the top 5 or 10 combined to ask for, then they might actually be good ones.
We've made the finals every year since Des has been there, making the top 4 would be cool, but it would mean absolutely nothing in terms of the team actually progressing, evolving and getting better every year like they should be aiming for. Want Des to get more creative? then the board should start with some creativity coming up with kpi's that require it.