Average All Star 17 of the last Decade

[Mitch Connor]

From that horror 2005 year to 2015 I wanna see everyone's thoughts on who were the most average players to get a run in the FG side.

2005 was top shelf for this.

1. Luke Young
2. Makasini Richter
3. Tim Winitana
7. Joe Williams
8. Fred Briggs
10. Ben Czislowski

Go.

 

[Mitch Connor]

13. Aaron Wheatley

 

[sultanofsydney]

5 heka nanai
6 brett oliver

 

[sultanofsydney]

1 Luke Young
2.luke macdougall
3. Tim Winitana
4 cameron phelps
5 heka nanai
6 brett oliver
7. Joe Williams
8. Fred Briggs
9 billy ngawini
10. Ben Czislowski
11 adam brideson
12 gary warburton
13 aaron weatley

14 charlie leaeno
15 sione kite
16 jake foster
17 reece blayney

 

[CrittaMagic69]

Brett lane has to be in the side

 

[sultanofsydney]

yeah i was reluctant to put phelps in didn't mind him but most our dodgy outside backs were wingers like lane, drury low, filiga filinga, nick youngquest

 

[Raysie]

Combine the 2005 and 2008 sides we had running out at the end of those years and that right there is the worst team you'll ever see running in the NRL.

 

[Moronic Musings]

1. Luke Young
2. Makasini Richter
3. Tim Winitana
4. Daniel Rauicava
5. Brett Lane
6. Daniel Holdsworth
7. Joe Williams
8. Fred Briggs
9. Billy Ngawini
10. Charlie Tonga
11. Gary Warburton
12. Frank Winterstein
13. Lorenzo Maufu

14. Heka Nanai
15. Ben Sczislowski
16. Aaron Wheatley
17. Charlie Leano

Special mention to Daryl Millard, the player with the least ability to be picked for so long

 

[Fully Sik Drop kick]

From that horror 2005 year to 2015 I wanna see everyone's thoughts on who were the most average players to get a run in the FG side.

2005 was top shelf for this.

1. Luke Young
2. Makasini Richter
3. Tim Winitana
7. Joe Williams
8. Fred Briggs
10. Ben Czislowski

Go.

lol you forgot Heka Nanai aka hektik

 

[Fully Sik Drop kick]

two of our worst seasons ever, 2005 and 2008, man don't know how we survived as fans those years,

 

[Pom_81]

Brett lane has to be in the side

He never got a regular run, though (thankfully.)

His one appearance was down in Wollongong and he was responsible for about 3 tries past him as we almost blew a big lead.

 

[terrylamb4lyfe]

Its a bit sad putting fred briggs in there. From memory didn't he have a full time day job and was just on match payments or something along those lines?

He was probably punching above his weight.

 

[adamsapple]

Its a bit sad putting fred briggs in there. From memory didn't he have a full time day job and was just on match payments or something along those lines?

He was probably punching above his weight.

Thats true
He was a carpenter at the time lol
Shows you how desperate we were and how bad our injury toll was

 

[BankstownBulldog]

Ben Czislowski is the single worst player I have ever seen play first grade football. Well him and that smith guys that played for Newcastle who told everyone he came from the NFL but was a massive hoax.

 

[Psycho Doggie]

Ben Czislowski is the single worst player I have ever seen play first grade football. Well him and that smith guys that played for Newcastle who told everyone he came from the NFL but was a massive hoax.

I was amazed how many games he actually got to play. He came in for the start of what season? All I remember is a big mop of hair speeding into the opposition defense before getting repelled back about 10 metres with even more speed, time after time after time...

 

[Psycho Doggie]

Its a bit sad putting fred briggs in there. From memory didn't he have a full time day job and was just on match payments or something along those lines?

He was probably punching above his weight.

Thats true
He was a carpenter at the time lol
Shows you how desperate we were and how bad our injury toll was

Yeah keep Briggsy off the list. He was never meant to play first grade, and when he got the desperate call up, he didn't do too bad. It probably helped that we had very little expectations of him.

 

[RO11LR]

Leon Bott

 

[Hacky McAxe]

Everyone seems to have forgotten about Jarrad Hickey

 

[The Greatest]

What about Leon Bolt?

 

[Kayser]

1 Luke Young
2.luke macdougall
3. Tim Winitana
4 cameron phelps
5 heka nanai
6 brett oliver
7. Joe Williams
8. Fred Briggs
9 billy ngawini
10. Ben Czislowski
11 adam brideson
12 gary warburton
13 aaron weatley

14 charlie leaeno
15 sione kite
16 jake foster
17 reece blayney

lol - I don't want to sound too harsh but **** me, what a bunch of shitbags.