topine hate?

[GA45]

Topine is little more than a journeyman. He just fills in when required.
Edwards offers a lot more. being a prop he will be an asset for years to come.
He reminds me of a younger Paul Harragon.

He better start learning to take some hit ups then !!

 

[bradyk]

It's the sickening jizz fest over average players.

Waddell is a far better player than Topine but he doesn't have the pashun & deeziyah so he is not in the good books.

Waddell's a human statue that destroys the attack in the final 3rd as well as an error and penalty magnet, hopefully doesn't feature at all next year.

 

[CMP]

Edwards offers a lot more. being a prop he will be an asset for years to come.
He reminds me of a younger Paul Harragon.

Edwards is as lucky to play 1st grade as Steve Turner was to play Origin.

He so far off a first grader it’s scary. He is terrible in defence and offers nothing in attack. He definitely has compromising footage of Harry Potter. How he got picked in the first place is amazing. The fact he keeps getting picked is mind boggling.

 

[Dan2]

A player that performs extremely well week after week in NSWcup and in his first full start in FG performs well gets dropped to the bench the following week. Maybe it is his size but to be honest i rather him start at second row with Jackson coming off the bench. Topine runs a real good line and is great little tackler.

 

[enoughsaid]

Edwards played 73 mins on Friday and had 3 runs for 19 metres. Hopefully it’s just a one off but it’s a big step up playing boys in NSW cup to playing FG.

Jeremiah Nanai 7 runs for 41 metres against Easts

Topine can play reserves and step up and lead the song when we win in first grade .... that's his role

 

[Noeasyday]

Speedy has the weirdest fucking takes.

Thompson is an edge backrower

 

[CQDog]

Its almost like he just isn’t very good and his ceiling is incredibly low.Would be ticked off if Edwards is kept over Topine but still preferably don’t see why we need either. Just my opinion and feel free to disagree.

 

[Kempsey Dog]

Topine is little more than a journeyman. He just fills in when required.
Edwards offers a lot more. being a prop he will be an asset for years to come.
He reminds me of a younger Paul Harragon.

Would have to be on looks and not ability lol

 

[Kempsey Dog]

The club/Gould's doing a lot of good things but I personally think how Topine's been treated this year is wrong. The kid bleeds blue and white and is more talented then a lot of players picked ahead of him (e.g. Waddell, Stimson, Edwards, Morrin, etc.)

Exactly, if we lose him but then give someone like Josh Reynolds a 1 year deal I'll be pissed

 

[2144superman]

Lol what hate? Some just aren't convinced he's a superstar. Topine indifference would be a more accurate term. If you want examples of players who get legit hate on here look no further than Adam Elliott, yours truly or the bloke you are using as an avatar.

Elliot is killing it for Canberra and I dare say had the last laugh

 

[InGusWeTrust]

Both Edwards and Topine don't impress me. Dunno why Morrin got dropped. Thought he showed lots of upside tbh.

 

[EL Hefe]

I'm not a fan of 4pines.... I hope that helps

 

[billy beane]

Edwards is as lucky to play 1st grade as Steve Turner was to play Origin.

He so far off a first grader it’s scary. He is terrible in defence and offers nothing in attack. He definitely has compromising footage of Harry Potter. How he got picked in the first place is amazing. The fact he keeps getting picked is mind boggling.

Harrison Edwards

72 tackles made.

4 tackles missed.

94.7% efficiency, in his two games to date.

Off topic .... we made 377 tackles compared to The Warriors 260.

Little wonder we faded after a short turnaround.

 

[CaptainJackson]

Hes too small. Other teams are having tall, big 2nd rowers as their strike weapons next to their halves. These big 2nd rowers are hard to tackle close to the line, Topine has been beaten many times in those situations.

He's too small to tackle the big forwards. Yes he's relatively the same size as Cam Murray or Radley but no way in he'll does he tackle like either of those players.

 

[Dognacious]

I havent seen this hate you speak of. Cant be that widespread you needed a thread about it lol. Topine is ok. Looks better when hes playing NSW Cup. Hes a reasonable backup. Doesnt give me wood but hes also not hopeless.

 

[Family Guy]

Elliot is killing it for Canberra and I dare say had the last laugh

He's off to Newcastle next year to be coached by O'Brian. They'll be doing well to avoid the spoon
We landed Ciraldo and should be top 8 certainties next year. We'll get the last laugh

 

[senshidog]

Wouldn't be suprised if Topines already been retained for next season based on his past few games in NRL.

 

[Flanagun]

Elliot is killing it for Canberra and I dare say had the last laugh

Yep. Meanwhile most of our forwards are cream puffs. Good call Gus

 

[Dognacious]

Yep. Meanwhile most of our forwards are cream puffs. Good call Gus

Meanwhile when Elliott was here, everyone at the kennel bagged him and wanted him gone.

 

[Flanagun]

Meanwhile when Elliott was here, everyone at the kennel bagged him and wanted him gone.

Yep. Coz they’re herpas lol