Nah he had to face the men for the first time as well they all weren't on debut in a cycloneBoth teams played in the same conditions did they not? Your argument very flawed.
JAC is always off his wing so is he not first grade standard either?I don’t think he ready for FG ,I saw some of the replays,he came off his wing to much ,one time he came off the wing and didn’t make the tackle so Kiraz went outside Declan to stop a player
Wighton is a rep player, Casey is barely a reserve grader. Big difference.Jack Wighton 6 errors today
Players have off games
Can happen in your first game and it can happen after 200 games
You entirely miss the point so often! error count very similar between the 2 nothing to do with being a rep player, except that both can have bad days.Wighton is a rep player, Casey is barely a reserve grader. Big difference.
I'm missing nothing, you are. This is nothing new with Casey, he has had these type of games in reserves, Flegg, etc. He just isn't any good.You entirely miss the point so often! error count very similar between the 2 nothing to do with being a rep player, except that both can have bad days.
So you forget how to catch a ball and the basics because you’re not playing against retards? He literally just kept dropping the ball over and over…Nah he had to face the men for the first time as well they all weren't on debut in a cyclone
Are you finished or are you done ?Hope the kid is ok. I hope the kid is given more chances in 1st grade this season, as we aren't going to achieve anything other than let young kids debut and get over nerves. I like to give kids 10 to 15 games before I start forming opinions & even then I can be wrong at times. I put Averillo in the dumpster but he has been reasonably good at fullback so far. Okenbur on the other hand I want kept in the dumspter. I would like to know why we aren't giving topine more goes in 1st grade. He seems to be a player in the mold of Rouben Cotter.
It's 1 game mate take it easy, if everyone that made there debuts were judged on that game alone then we wouldn't have a competition. Kid should be given a fair go just like the restYou can't compare to patolo at all. He made some errors in his debut but also made some good runs. Declan did nothing but fck up in attack and defence. Every involvement in the game he made led to shit. This bloke should never be considered for first grade again
You're right - emotional response and i was a little hard on him. I hope he bounces back n NSW cup and earns another shot. In saying that it feels like the bulldogs have debuted a few too many players over the past few years who are not first grade quality.It's 1 game mate take it easy, if everyone that made there debuts were judged on that game alone then we wouldn't have a competition. Kid should be given a fair go just like the rest
You just proved my point!I'm missing nothing, you are. This is nothing new with Casey, he has had these type of games in reserves, Flegg, etc. He just isn't any good.
I agree with you on that, it does seem like we debut someone every few weeks lately lolIt's 1 game mate take it easy, if everyone that made there debuts were judged on that game alone then we wouldn't have a competition. Kid should be given a fair go just like the rest
thats harsh mate, very tough conditions, hed be as nervous as fuck, not sure what level you have played at but anyone who has played grade is a very good player.I'm missing nothing, you are. This is nothing new with Casey, he has had these type of games in reserves, Flegg, etc. He just isn't any good.