Who would you drop?

[Trafford10]

If you could only make one change for next week, who would you leave out?

 

[Scoooby]

Montoya gone!!!

 

[Baseball Furies]

*Waits for the Elliott haters to come forward...

I'm expecting an avalanche

 

[Freakzilla]

*Waits for the Elliott haters to come forward...

I'm expecting an avalanche

I don't hate any Bulldogs player. I just want us to win or build into a winner. Montoya and Elliott shouldn't be anywhere near the first grade side.

 

[haytchcbb]

I’d drop
Montonya
Elliot

 

[DoggieDogg]

Montoya
Hoppa
Holland - give him more minutes or dont bother
Eastwood - get a fresh blood in he is past it

 

[Emdog85]

I don't hate any Bulldogs player. I just want us to win or build into a winner. Montoya and Elliott shouldn't be anywhere near the first grade side.

Elliott going better than Hoppa, he's useless this season, as is Montoya but if I had to choose one it'd be Hoppa

 

[Raysie]

Montoya for me. He's a shadow of the form he was showing in 2017. He want from being safe and sound on the wing to now being a complete turnstyle and unreliable under the high ball.

I'd put Hopoate on that Wing and try something different at right centre.

EDIT: Add Fualalo to the list. He's been awful.

 

[coach]

*Waits for the Elliott haters to come forward...

I'm expecting an avalanche

I'm not an Elliot fan, but at the end of the day those isp boys arnt stepping up
Team not travelling good, but unfortunately no one is knocking the door down
And I can't see to many upgrades by dropping our fg players!
Nu brown might offer more in attack then jmk, maybe just maybe
Might not either, so I can't see anyone getting dropped

 

[Trafford10]

Montoya for me. He's a shadow of the form he was showing in 2017. He want from being safe and sound on the wing to now being a complete turnstyle and unreliable under the high ball.

I'd put Hopoate on that Wing and try something different at right centre.

EDIT: Add Fualalo to the list. He's been awful.

He’s there.

 

[Kempsey Dog]

Lichaa because thats where the problems begin...

1. Mbye
2. Holland
3. J.Morris
4. Hopoate
5. B.Morris
6. Lewis (im torn here, want him to get a run asap, but playing centre for a while now, he would be a little out of sorts imo)
7. Foran
8. Woods
9. Marshall-King
10. Klemmer
11. Fine
12. Mariner
13. Jackson (c)

14. Brown
15. Eastwood
16. To'Omaga
17. Ogden

Thats the side I want to see but we wont...
I was originally torn on Martin or Fine, however Asepeli has impressed me a few times over the last 2 weeks, would make a good stop gap solution until we get more cap space.
As for the bench, Renouf and Ogden have done enough to warrant a shot.

 

[KiwiDog7]

Lichaa

 

[BondiBulldog]

Should be an avalanche to Lichaa. He is 100 times more detrimental than any other player in the NRL.
Someone mentioned K. Pritchard is the only worse hooker in the NRL, no. Lichaa is way worse.
Although I watched the last three games last year I did not concentrate that much on Lichaa's passing. So I don't know what it was like. I'm still sure it would've been extremely poor.
No one thought much on Lichaa and never expected him to run so maybe that's why he went so well.
I do admit I can't remember the game but I find it hard to believe he did anything great besides run which was allowed cause he was (rightfully) so under estimated.
I have noticed the flaws in Lichaa since day one and NEVER wanted him re-signed.
We would be in the 8 now even if we had K. Pritchard as our 9. I think we'd be 4 from 7.

 

[Raysie]

He’s there.

LOL sorry I meant add him to my list.

 

[diddly]

There is so little depth - apart from Toomaga, Brown, Martin and Olive- who at best are borderline first graders - no one stands out as an improvement on who is already in first grade. Lewis defence is excellent but he is not a centre. Hopefully anyone who in the past who has suggested Okunbar or Smith have watched the NSW cup games on TV - realise what grade their defence is suitable for.

 

[BMOC]

Montoya needs to be dropped and Holland or Olive need to come in. Last year i would have said that Montoya was playing better than BMoz. This year Montoya is really out of form in attack. I know his defence is bad but i want him dropped because he has not made up in attack. He hasn't offered anything in attack.

 

[doggieaaron]

1)mbye
2)bmoz
3)jmoz
4)olive
5)holland
6)lewis
7)foz
13)eastwood
12jacko
11)rfm
10)woods
9)jmk
8)klem
Bench)danny f (but fuck he needs to improve),renouf t /francis t /lichha

 

[Mr Invisible]

There are too many individual problems.
Montoya - because he rares sees any ball these days.
Hoppa - because he offers nothing in attack or defence in the centres.
Lichaa - because his forms inconsistent.
Elliott - for same reason as Lichaa.

 

[Dingo]

Fualalo needs to free a bench spot up

 

[CaptainJackson]

Elliot
Elliot
And elliot