THE NINE GREATEST FINALS CHOKES OF ALL-TIME

Status
Not open for further replies.

Vlasnik

Kennel Legend
Joined
Nov 16, 2011
Messages
10,442
Reaction score
8,181
Since popular opinion believes that we are destined to cop a hiding this coming Sunday at the hands of the Panthers and be thrown out the finals in the first week. I thought we should take a look at the top 9 chokes of all time. To those who are thinking why not the top 10 well just wait till Sunday. :grinning:


THE NINE GREATEST FINALS CHOKES OF ALL-TIME
By Rocco Luca


WE’VE seen some great finals moments throughout the years filled with displays of individual brilliance and remarkable committment to succeed.

But what about the other end of the spectrum? When the moment becomes too much and individuals and teams tighten up and buckle with their shot at glory beckoning.

So, with the preliminary finals less than a week away, we at RLW have trawled through the archives and put our heads together to bring you the nine greatest finals chokes of all-time.

Enjoy . . .

9. South Sydney v Manly, 2013 preliminary final

Playing in their second grand final qualifier in as many years, Souths looked odds-on to reach their first grand final since 1971 when they raced to a 14-0 lead early in this high-stakes encounter against the Sea Eagles. However, the occasion once again got the better of the Bunnies as the Sea Eagles produced a remarkable second half recovery to chalk up a strong 30-20 win and qualify for their forth grand final in seven years.



8. South Sydney v Balmain, 1969 grand final

In one of the greatest boilovers in grand final history, a Balmain side full of rookies and no-names managed to topple a star-studded Rabbitohs side to the tune of 12-2 to take out their 11th premiership title. Souths were minor premiers that year and had beaten Balmain two weeks earlier in the major semi-final but had no answer to the Tigers’ stifling defensive display.

7. St George v Canterbury, 1985 grand final

In 1985 Saints were on the verge of emulating the heroics of their 1963 squad by winning all three grades in the NSWRL competition. Both their Under 23s and Reserve Grade sides got up, but firsts faltered, mainly due to Warren Ryan’s ingenious game plan which involved Canterbury halfback Steve Mortimer continually bombing Saints fullback Glen Burgess in-goal, forcing numerous line drop outs and starving Roy Masters’ side of the ball. An Andrew Farrar field goal proved the difference in the 7-6 score line, but this wasn’t a true indication of Canterbury’s dominance.



6. Parramatta v North Queensland, 2005 preliminary final

Many members of Parramatta’s 2005 team still consider this the lowest point of their careers. Minor premiers in 2005, Parramatta cruised into the grand final qualifier after a comprehensive win over Manly in opening week of the finals. However, they had an absolute shocker in the preliminary final going down to a red-hot Cowboys side 29-0 at Telstra Stadium. According to former hooker Mark Riddell, the fact that the Wests Tigers ended up winning Premiership that year proved particularly painful.

“The worst thing was that we had watched the Dragons lose to the Tigers the night before. We had comfortably beaten Wests twice that year and thought we were morals for the Premiership,” Riddell told RLW earlier this year.



5. Manly v Sydney Bulldogs, 1995 grand final

In 1995 Manly were on fire. Minor premiers, they started the year with 13 consecutive victories and ended up just dropping two games in the lead up to the last Sunday of September. The Bulldogs on the other hand had scraped into the finals in sixth place after being almost torn apart by the Super League war. Manly had crushed the Dogs 26-0 last time they met, but that meant nothing as the Terry Lamb led Blue-and-Whites completely shut the minor premiers out of the game, chalking up an impressive 17-4 win.



LOOK @ DES HAHAHAHAHA

4. Parramatta v Newcastle, 2001 grand final

Brian Smith’s Eels were one of the great sides of the modern era. Attacking dynamos, they smashed the record for most points scored by an individual team during a season racking up 948 points, 72 more than the previous record-holders, the 1998 Broncos. However, they choked big time in the grand final, allowing the Andrew Johns-inspired Knights to race to a 24-0 lead by half time. Parramatta performed valiantly during the second half getting back within six points late in the second half, however the Knights always seemed to hold the ascendency.



3. Parramatta v Canterbury, 1998 preliminary final

Canterbury’s dream run to the 1998 grand final from 9th place looked all but over late in the preliminary final against the Eels holding an 18-2 advantage with just over 10 minutes to spare. However, in one of the greatest comebacks in modern history, Canterbury managed to draw level by the end of regulation time, helped in part by a couple of calamitous mistakes from Eels fullback Paul Carige. Halfback Craig Polla-Mounter starred for the Dogs in extra time scoring one try and kicking two field goals to lift Canterbury to an unlikely 32-20 win.



2. Balmain v Canberra, 1989 grand final

Overwhelming favourites leading into the 1989 decider, Balmain took the early ascendency with two somewhat fluky tries to James Grant and Paul Sironen, giving them a 14-2 lead at the break. The Tigers had three clear opportunities to put the game to bed during the second half but failed to convert. These included; five-eighth Mick Neil being ankle tapped just short of the try-line by Mal Meninga, Wayne Pearce dropping the ball with the line wide open and Benny Elias’ field goal attempt hitting the crossbar. Ageless winger Chika Ferguson forced the game into extra time with a try in the 79th minute, before the Raiders sealed the final with a field goal and try during extra time.



1. St George Illawarra v Melbourne, 1999 grand final

St George Illawarra looked on their way to scoring a premiership in their inaugural season after tries to Nathan Blacklock and Craig Fitzgibbon saw them lead the Storm 14-0 at half time. However, a bombed try from Anthony Mundine 10 minutes into the second stanza triggered a horror collapse from the Saints with Melbourne grabbing three quick tries, including Craig Smith’s 78th minute penalty try, to steal one of the most controversial grand finals in history.





http://rugbyleagueweek.com.au/henry-needed-surgery-april/
 

Vlasnik

Kennel Legend
Joined
Nov 16, 2011
Messages
10,442
Reaction score
8,181

Look at who was playing for Para that Day???? :grinning: Ohh mother say a pray for me Jimmy's back in town it want be easy ;)

Canterbury Bankstown Bulldogs Parramatta Eels
32
20
Match Stats
Halftime Score

Scrums 4 8
Penalties 4 4
Match Scoresheet
Tries
Craig POLLA-MOUNTER (2) Shane WHEREAT (2)
Travis NORTON Clinton SCHIFCOFSKE
Rod SILVA
Willie TALAU
Goals Daryl HALLIGAN (5/6) Clinton SCHIFCOFSKE (3/4)
John SIMON (1/1)
Field Goals Craig POLLA-MOUNTER (2)
Teams
Fullback
1. Rod SILVA 1. Clinton SCHIFCOFSKE
Wing 2. Gavin LESTER 2. Paul CARIGE
Centre 3. Willie TALAU 3. Stuart KELLY
Centre 4. Shane MARTEENE 4. Karl LOVELL
Wing 5. Daryl HALLIGAN 5. Shane WHEREAT
Five-Eighth 6. Craig POLLA-MOUNTER 6. Jason SMITH
Halfback 7. Corey HUGHES 7. John SIMON
Front Row 8. Darren BRITT (c) 8. Dean PAY (c)
Hooker 9. Jason HETHERINGTON 9. Aaron RAPER
Front Row 10. Steve PRICE 10. Mark TOOKEY
Second Row 11. Robert RELF 11. Jarrod McCRACKEN (c)
Second Row 12. Tony GRIMALDI 12. Nathan HINDMARSH
Lock 13. Travis NORTON 13. Jim DYMOCK
Bench 14. David THOMPSON 14. Jason BELL
Bench 15. Troy STONE 15. Nathan CAYLESS
Bench 16. Matthew RYAN 16. Dallas WESTON
Bench 17. Glen HUGHES 17. David PENNA
Coach Steve FOLKES Brian SMITH
 

blueyedsamurai

Kennel Legend
Joined
Sep 18, 2012
Messages
11,321
Reaction score
2,554
Parramatta are surely the kings of the choke. No matter how good their side is they just cant seem to win a GF.
 

Vlasnik

Kennel Legend
Joined
Nov 16, 2011
Messages
10,442
Reaction score
8,181
Last edited:

The DoggFather

ASSASSIN
Premium Member
Gilded
Site's Top Poster
Joined
Sep 2, 2012
Messages
107,955
Reaction score
120,740
What about our choke against Brisbane. Forgot what year it was.
 

Vlasnik

Kennel Legend
Joined
Nov 16, 2011
Messages
10,442
Reaction score
8,181
The rule has changed thanks to us but this is what happens when you have a true halfback: but firsts faltered, mainly due to Warren Ryan’s ingenious game plan which involved Canterbury halfback Steve Mortimer continually bombing Saints fullback Glen Burgess in-goal, forcing numerous line drop outs and starving Roy Masters’ side of the ball.
 

Baseball Furies

Kennel Enthusiast
Gilded
Joined
Jan 6, 2007
Messages
3,948
Reaction score
4,921
We had a great side in 1995:

Fullback 1. Rod SILVA
Wing 2. Gavin LESTER
Centre 3. Willie TALAU
Centre 4. Shane MARTEENE
Wing 5. Daryl HALLIGAN
Five-Eighth 6. Craig POLLA-MOUNTER
Halfback 7. Corey HUGHES
Front Row 8. Darren BRITT (c)
Hooker 9. Jason HETHERINGTON
Front Row 10. Steve PRICE
Second Row 11. Robert RELF
Second Row 12. Tony GRIMALDI
Lock 13. Travis NORTON
Bench 14. David THOMPSON
Bench 15. Troy STONE 15.
Bench 16. Matthew RYAN
Bench 17. Glen HUGHES
CoachSteve FOLKES

I have no idea where Terry Lamb was that day???? Must have been injured.
That's the 1998 team not 1995, Baa was well and truly enjoying retirement by 1998 (retired in 1996).
 

Vlasnik

Kennel Legend
Joined
Nov 16, 2011
Messages
10,442
Reaction score
8,181
That's the 1998 team not 1995, Baa was well and truly enjoying retirement by 1998 (retired in 1996).
Yeah thanks for that mate must get my glasses checked, great pick up!!! Why the hell was I thinking 95??? 1998 still a great team puts our current team to shame.
 

Baseball Furies

Kennel Enthusiast
Gilded
Joined
Jan 6, 2007
Messages
3,948
Reaction score
4,921
95 Bulldogs Grand Final Team:

Fullback: Rod Silva
Wing: Jason Williams
Centre: John Timu
Centre: Matthew Ryan
Wing: Daryl Halligan
Five Eight: Terry Lamb
Halfback: Craig Polla-Mounter
Lock: Jim Dymock
Second Row: Simon Gillies
Second Row: Steve Price
Prop: Dean Pay
Hooker: Jason Hetherington
Prop: Darren Britt

Reserve: Jason Smith
Reserve: Glen Hughes
Reserve: Mitch Newton

Now that was a team!

Plenty of tough bastards across the park...could teach a bunch of our current squad a thing or two...
 

Baseball Furies

Kennel Enthusiast
Gilded
Joined
Jan 6, 2007
Messages
3,948
Reaction score
4,921
That's the 1998 team not 1995, Baa was well and truly enjoying retirement by 1998 (retired in 1996).
Yeah thanks for that mate must get my glasses checked, great pick up!!! Why the hell was I thinking 95??? 1998 still a great team puts our current team to shame.
I figured you got your digits mixed up >:(

Agreed on your last comment also mate.
 

Vlasnik

Kennel Legend
Joined
Nov 16, 2011
Messages
10,442
Reaction score
8,181

Vlasnik

Kennel Legend
Joined
Nov 16, 2011
Messages
10,442
Reaction score
8,181
95 Bulldogs Grand Final Team:

Fullback: Rod Silva
Wing: Jason Williams
Centre: John Timu
Centre: Matthew Ryan
Wing: Daryl Halligan
Five Eight: Terry Lamb
Halfback: Craig Polla-Mounter
Lock: Jim Dymock
Second Row: Simon Gillies
Second Row: Steve Price
Prop: Dean Pay
Hooker: Jason Hetherington
Prop: Darren Britt

Reserve: Jason Smith
Reserve: Glen Hughes
Reserve: Mitch Newton

Now that was a team!

Plenty of tough bastards across the park...could teach a bunch of our current squad a thing or two...
Beat me to it buddy :grinning:
 

Vlasnik

Kennel Legend
Joined
Nov 16, 2011
Messages
10,442
Reaction score
8,181
Great minds, my friend...
Haslers' Manly side had it's ass smacked by our Grand Final winning side of 1995, which makes it even sweeter, 17-4 I believe the score was at the end and Bullfrog embracing Terry Lamb after the match priceless!!! :hearteyes:
 

CroydonDog

Kennel Immortal
Gilded
Joined
Aug 1, 2012
Messages
19,615
Reaction score
16,696
I went to that game in 98 with a large group of Parra supporters.

What a comeback. Polly was on fire.
 

Dogzof95

Kennel Enthusiast
Joined
Apr 5, 2016
Messages
3,205
Reaction score
2,527
Here is our Grand Final winning side of 1995,


Fullback 1. Rod SILVA
Wing 18. Jason WILLIAMS
Centre 3. John TIMU
Centre 4. Matthew RYAN
Wing 5. Daryl HALLIGAN
Five-Eighth 6. Terry LAMB (c) LEGEND
Halfback
7. Craig POLLA-MOUNTER 7.
Front Row 8. Darren BRITT 8.
Hooker 9. Jason HETHERINGTON
Front Row 10. Dean PAY
Second Row 11. Steve PRICE
Second Row 12. Simon GILLIES
Lock 13. Jim DYMOCK
Bench 25. Jason SMITH
Bench 27. Glen HUGHES
Bench 28. Mitch NEWTON
Coach Chris ANDERSON
If this team had stayed together we would be talking about a dynasty no doubt about it!
 

Lil Ms Fabulous

Is Trollin
Joined
Mar 29, 2005
Messages
4,386
Reaction score
574
I can still remember how cocky those Eels were the afternoon of 29-0. Especially when it came to Hindmarsh
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top