Is this an option...

[MrCharisma]

Off Contract in 08
Unwanted in 09
Former N.S.W halfback
Premiership winner
Organiser
Experienced
Dangerous
Handed us a hiding

Kill me now for even THINKING about this, but is this experienced campaigner the player we need for 2009? I can't imagine him playing at the Dogs but it seems we're unhappy with our halves choices... Barba offered no glimpes of light today, Roberts and Holdsworth lost the plot despite a huge lead.

Is this an option or do we keep using untested or non-working players? For instant success the void must be filled.

Most of you will thrash this thread but anyone with a brain will consider the option and think it through...
​

 

[Such Is Life]

i wouldnt like to see him in the blue and white , but i could see him having more of an impact then what our halves are having at the moment .. i say sign him

 

[bLaQDoG..]

Is that who i think it is?!?!

Have you got rocks in ur head Mr C!!!!

HELLL NOO!!!!! *pukes lungs and entire colon out*

 

[Doggiez04]

as much as i cant stand the guy, i wouldn't mind him donning the blue and white. would certainly be better than what we have at at the moment

 

[TCB-BD]

NO NO and oh yes... NO... he is an alright player.. but he is not a Bulldog... END OF STORY!

 

[MrCharisma]

Is that who i think it is?!?!

Have you got rocks in ur head Mr C!!!!

HELLL NOO!!!!! *pukes lungs and entire colon out*

Do you think I like the idea... just like when Craig Wing was linked to the Dogs, I didn't jump for joy but I could see the benifits of him joining our club since we have a void.

 

[MattyB]

you drunk or what, no, no and NO

 

[pha_t0ny]

i think troubled times have affected your judgement mrC, i couldnt care less if he's a gud player HE IS NOT A BULLDOG end of story

 

[MrCharisma]

Not to mention we have lots of money to burn, lost out on Folau and Carney... doesn't look likely to sign Webb.

If there were other options, I'd go for them first... but unless you want to recruit from England or want to stick with Roberts/Holdsworth, Finch is unfortunately and option

 

[chadiwrx]

Hell ****ing NO

 

[~doggie~diva~]

no way..

 

[chadiwrx]

If he ends up in the blue & white i'll stop watching the Doggies play.

 

[pha_t0ny]

Not to mention we have lots of money to burn, lost out on Folau and Carney... doesn't look likely to sign Webb.

If there were other options, I'd go for them first... but unless you want to recruit from England or want to stick with Roberts/Holdsworth, Finch is unfortunately an option

key word being option, and my option would be no, not in a million years
bred not bought
besides, i dont think were in a predicament so dire that we need him
of all people

 

[bLaQDoG..]

Do you think I like the idea... just like when Craig Wing was linked to the Dogs, I didn't jump for joy but I could see the benifits of him joining our club since we have a void.

Im sorry but that guy could win us a premiership for the next seven years and i just wont like him...

Yuck!

 

[Bitemarks]

I'd say yes, great replacement for Holdsworth, we might even get better treatment from the refs as a bonus

 

[Game Breaker]

We havnt reached that far yet

 

[ash160]

I'd rather bring back Shifty Sherwin!!!

 

[Hammer]

if neither groom or barba are going to do the job, then yes of course, he's a very talented footballer - everyone who watched tonight will know that

 

[Bakes]

Ill take a loss

 

[Bluebody]

If he ends up in the blue & white i'll stop watching the Doggies play.

liar